I also have the Rotary Plow from Earth Tools and have used it to plow up about an acre of alfalfa in the past year (along with my 12
HP BCS 850). It makes a good seedbed in one pass and generally the alfalfa does not come back. It works best in softer soil. When it soil is hard it makes handlebars vibrate and the plow does dig deeply.
The main disadvantages for me are:
1) Slow - when plowing up alfalfa I need to go in first gear and the plow takes at most a 12"
cut with each pass. It takes about 2.5 hours to plow an area 16'X150'.
2) It leaves a furrow. It may not be clear from the pictures which have been posted that the plow works by cutting into the soil on the left and throwing it to the right. You work the plow by running the right wheel of the tractor in the furrow from the previous pass, and the left wheel of the tractor on the unplowed ground.
The height of the hood over the plow can be adjusted, and a shield can be installed on the left side of the plow to reduce the dirt-throw. However, I have not found a configuration which will make the plow not leave a furrow at all. The furrow can be a nusiance to deal with subsequently. It's an anklebreaker.
3) My biggest problem with the plow is that it is very difficult to use across a slope. (My slope is 5-10%). When I make a pass across the slope with the downslope on the left, the plow works wonderfully. However, on the return pass, with the upslope on my left, the plow is very difficult to use. The weight of the plow attachment drags it down slope, and away from the untilled ground which it should be augering into. As a result, the plow only takes a 2" or so
cut into the untilled ground unless you constantly muscle it into the unplowed ground. This is a constant problem for me. If anyone else has used the plow on a slope I would be very interested in hearing their experiences.
I agree with all the praise given to Joel from Earth Tools in Kentucky. A wonderful guy.