Spreader Which Spreader Herd M96 or Befco 206-121?

   / Which Spreader Herd M96 or Befco 206-121? #1  

jcaledon

Bronze Member
Joined
Jan 20, 2008
Messages
85
Location
Ontario, Canada
Tractor
Kubota B2620, Kubota G1800-S 4WS
Just bought a Kubota B2620, which will be delivered shortly. I need a broadcast spreader (300 pound hopper) to spread lawn fertilizer and seed. I will not be using it for salt or sand. I have approx 2 1/2 acres of lawn. I am located in Ontario Canada.

I have read some pretty good reviews on the Herd M96 spreader. However, the price on the spreader here in Canada is approx $625. I could order it from Herd directly, but would have to pay duties and shipping which would bring the cost up to about that anyways, in fact Herd suggested I just call their distributor in Canada which is where I got the quote for $625. I would have to drive an hour and a half to pick it up.

My Kubota dealer sells the Befco spreader. The price is $650, and it can be added to my order. I haven't heard too much about this brand of spreader. The hopper is painted steel, not galvanized like the Herd, and overall it doesn't seem as solid as the Herd. But then again, the design is a little different, so maybe I'm comparing apples and oranges.

I would prefer to pick up the spreader with the tractor and be done with it. But $650 is a lot of money to spend on broadcast spreader - so I want it to last forever - I've heard a lot of people complain that these things rust very quickly.

Which one is the better unit? Is the Befco going to rust quickly, even with good maintenance? The Befco unit I was quoted on does not have the stainless steel components - I'm sure that unit would cost considerably more.

In addition to the above, any advise you could provide on the use of organic fertilizer would be great. I would like to move away from chemicals, and move completely to organic or natural fertilizers, but there seems to be very little information out there. I have only found Scotts Eco-sense, but that's only available in small bags. I don't want to spend a fortune - this stuff must be available in bulk somewhere. Any suggestions would be appreciated.
 
   / Which Spreader Herd M96 or Befco 206-121? #2  
BEFCO - Products - Fertilizer spreaders - Hop

Herd Seeder - Seeders, Spreaders and Feeders

Here is a third alternative...:D
Ag Equipment USA

Baltimatic Fertilizer Spreader
The Baltimatic Fertilizer Spreader is the new approach in modern fertilizer/seeder equipment. Filled with surprising features like the extra heavy duty gearbox with lubrication ability and safety guard to cover the PTO shaft, and the 6 galvanized adjustable distribution wings for perfect fertilizer distribution, the Baltimatic will make you a happy owner.

Specifications:
Covers 7-15 acres per hour
40-4000 lbs. output per acre
Speed - 2-10 MPH
Weight - 220 lbs.
Spreading width (granulated) 33'-50'

Manual...
http://www.agequipmentusa.com/agequ...tic Model 80 Fertilizer Spreader & Seeder.pdf
 
   / Which Spreader Herd M96 or Befco 206-121? #3  
The Herd

top notch, incredibly well built, those little touches that well used to be standard.
throws an amazing pattern.

I won't buy anything else in spreaders anymore.
 
   / Which Spreader Herd M96 or Befco 206-121? #4  
I agree, get the heard, cost a little more but worth it in accuracy. Also, if set up properly you wont be able to see 'streaks' from a poor spread pattern. When we used ours if we had time we would spread at 1/2 rate and cover twice at 45 deg angle. This helps ensure a more even coverage, especially if broadcasting something light like seed.

DuaneW.
 
   / Which Spreader Herd M96 or Befco 206-121?
  • Thread Starter
#5  
Hi Everyone,

Took your advice and picked up the Herd M-96 yesterday. From all accounts it represents the best value. The unit seems very well built. I bought it from the distributor here in Ontario, Canada. I didn't want to order it online, pay for the shipping which would have been expensive, plus whatever duties etc I would get hit with, etc. It came with the lid, and I was very disappointed to see that the lid was all scratched up straight out of the box. I've read somewhere that this is quite common. The dealer apologized for the condition of the lid, and discounted the unit somewhat to make up for it. The discount will pay for as much orange paint as I will need to repaint the entire unit so that it matches the new Kubota I have just ordered.

I'm looking forward to using it. I have found a company here in Southern Ontario that sells organic granular fertilizer in 50 lb bags - Gaia Green. There seems to be some good reviews on it on the web. Has anyone used this, or a similar product. Any input would be appreciated. I would really like to stop using chemical fertilizers on my lawn. The organic stuff seems to be an environmentally friendly alternative that will hopefully keep my lawn looking great.
 
   / Which Spreader Herd M96 or Befco 206-121? #6  
jcaledon - who/where is the distributer? What did it cost you at the end if you don't mind me asking?

I've also heard great things about the Herd.
 
   / Which Spreader Herd M96 or Befco 206-121?
  • Thread Starter
#7  
canoetrpr said:
jcaledon - who/where is the distributer? What did it cost you at the end if you don't mind me asking?

I've also heard great things about the Herd.

canoetrpr,

I got it from Innovative Ag in Stratford. I wouldn't have driven down there just to get the spreader, but I had a meeting in London this week, so I made a detour before my meeting and picked it up. The price was $610 plus tax. He (Wayne) took off another $15 for the scratches on the lid. Note that the price includes the lid and spring, which appears to be an option on the Herd web site. I was given their name and number from Herd directly. When I asked Herd if they shipped to Canada, they said that they would, but that it would make more sense to just buy directly from Innovative, because the shipping costs etc. would erase any savings I would otherwise get. The price was a lot less than what I was quoted for the Befco. One dealer wanted $700, while Larkin wanted $800 (I had already ordered the tractor - I bet the price would have been close to the $700 if I had negotiated it at the time) for the Befco. The Herd just looks like a more solid product.
 
   / Which Spreader Herd M96 or Befco 206-121? #8  
jcaledon - just curious - did you look at the S3B Model? If so, why did you choose the M96 over it - both are 3 bushel. the flex PTO shaft looked interesting

Anyone else have either model?

I've been trying to get a spreader for over a month - been leary to buy one online. TSC has the smaller XB model (5 bu) but my store doesn't stock it. My Dealer carries Befco and Landpride. He had a smaller Befco, which was perfect for what I want - but the bottom of the hopper was already rusting/corroded - just by sitting outside (paint had flaked off). He told me he had the smaller Landprides coming in weeks ago - but they haven't got in yet - he has been contacting me weekly - evidently there are issues with the distributor. But even so, looking at their website, the Landpride looks exactly like the King Kutter (made by cosmo I think). The Landpride FSB500 is more $$ than the KK so it it is in fact the same, I will pass on it.

Would welcome any input on any of the other brands - but like the Herd now - glad I caught this post

Thanks
Eric
 
   / Which Spreader Herd M96 or Befco 206-121? #9  
I have a landpride spreader, and it's a pretty good spreader
But the Herd is levels beyond it.
Build quality, quality of materials, etc

Really, I bought my first Herd just after searching online forever and ever and I'm more than pleased. Excellent value for the money. And I can break everything (ask around) and I haven't broken it. (I did break the agitator in the landpride, but that must happen a lot because the part was really cheap)

I've probably fertilized 200+ acres just this spring (all in 1 to 30 acre plots for customers)

The Herd just works.
 
   / Which Spreader Herd M96 or Befco 206-121? #10  
I just got a M96 delivered today by Fedex. It looks like it should last.

dale
 
 
 
Top