Hi All, (What a Great Forum.)
I'd like the skinny on dirt buckets & boom poles.
I have an older, but solid Kubota B7100D 4x4 (16.5/12 hp) with 5' scraper blade, 4' brush hog & 4' finish mower. All came as a package.
While a FEL would be nice ... lift stuff w/ a boom. I don't mind taking small bites to get the job done with less than ideal solutions where the cost is 1/10 for the scoop and boom as compared to the FEL, but I don't want to throw $ down the rat hole either.
greater KC, KS to support my
"From 5 a.m. to 'bout noon I play farmer, After that my favorite attachments are a boat w/ boobs aboard and beer cooler."
I like your schedule too!
Like others have said, both tools will do the job they are designed for, and in some cases, better than front loader, but in most cases, not as well.
This latter comment is especially true for the B7100. The B7100 is a VERY capable little tractor, I know, I've owned two of them. BUT, the 3PH is quite limited in its lift capability, even compared to some other tractors of similar size. It is rated for 400 lbs. at 24" back from the pivots. My 2nd B7100 could actually lift about 550-600 LBS 18" back (load centered on a 36" pallet on a 3PH carry-all). A boom pole puts the load much futher back (like 6'), and the geometry of it (vs. a normal implement with a top link) give you about 3X more lift, and 3X less lift force at the end of the boom pole. You'll probably be limited to about 200 lbs at the end of the pole. This is still very useful, but about 40% of what B219 FEL on a B7100 can lift. One of the main reasons I sold my 2nd B7100 and got the B7610 was that I need more 3PH lift power (the B7610 is good for about 1300lbs at the pins, 1080lbs 24" back), for moving pallets of firewood, and other loads with the 3PH carry-all. I also got very frustrated using my PHD with the B7100, as it would get stuck very easily, and the B7100 didn't have enough lift power to get it back out.
The boom pole and dirt scoop are probably much more useful on the larger tractors of the era they came from (the Ford 8N was one of the smaller tractors of that time).
All that said, I would go ahead on get a boom pole and dirt scoop (esp. if you can get 'em cheaply used), and keep looking for either an FEL, or another B7100 with one. I've seen some older B7100's for sale this year with FEL for as little as $3200. You might be able to get a high-hours, or otherwise beat B7100 w/ FEL cheaply and move the FEL over to yours.
The B219 FEL that Kubota sold for early B7100's was also used on the B6100 (I don' t know if the subframe is different). Later B7100's used the 1630. My 2nd B7100 (and HST) had a Woods DuAl 145. The Woods was a very nice loader, with excellent lift power (680 lbs), and lift height (at 84", a full 15" higher than the LA352 on my B7610). If you (or a friend) have welding/fabrication skills, you could adapt a front loader from any other similar-sized tractor, or even build one.
Enjoy you B7100, and if you do get a FEL, fill the rear tires, and get a
ballast box or weight.