Tiller Opinons Gear Or Chain Drive

   / Opinons Gear Or Chain Drive #1  

boomer1025

Platinum Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2010
Messages
791
Location
Central Pa
Tractor
NH Boomer 1025
I'm going to get a tiller for my Boomer 1025. Been looking at the King Kutter brand because that's what my local TSC carries. The 2 models I'm interested in are 4 footers the TG 48 XB-O & the TG 48 Y. the BX is chain drive & the Y is gear drive. Big difference in weight & price. The XB weights about 400 & The Y is about 580. I like the XB for the cat 1/0, the weight & price $1230, the Y is $1600. My biggest concern is how well the chain drive will hold up compared to the gear drive.
 
   / Opinons Gear Or Chain Drive #2  
If there was a problem with the chain drive tillers, there would be people on here letting us know about it. I haven't heard of anybody having a problem with them, you'll be good with either one, I just don't like the XB stuff because the pins are closer together than all my other implements.
 
   / Opinons Gear Or Chain Drive #3  
I'm going to get a tiller for my Boomer 1025. Been looking at the King Kutter brand because that's what my local TSC carries. The 2 models I'm interested in are 4 footers the TG 48 XB-O & the TG 48 Y. the BX is chain drive & the Y is gear drive. Big difference in weight & price. The XB weights about 400 & The Y is about 580. I like the XB for the cat 1/0, the weight & price $1230, the Y is $1600. My biggest concern is how well the chain drive will hold up compared to the gear drive.




To till or not to till tis the question;



The method of power transmission to the attachment is strictly something the manufacturer decides upon.

The tiller should have a limited slip friction disc clutch or a shear pin in the
P.T.O., driveline as a matter of necessity for the attachment.

The roller chain drive reduces the speed of the right angle gearbox delivering
the energy to the roller chain via the sprockets.

The gear to gear drive also accomplishes this.

The gear to gear drive also reduces the speed of the rotation through the gear box and provides the attachement with slightly more force to rip the ground up.


The forward travel speed is the governing factor in this tillage method for either unit as the slower one travels listening to the fender radio with a cold one in in the can holder and a slice of warm pizza the easier it is to enjoy as long as the winds blowing to the rear.:licking:

More important is the tine type used whether it is the bolo tiller blade or the L tiller blade as it is strictly depending on the depth of tillage desired it will require more work depending on the soil.

The L tine is more aggresive than the bolo tine in the first pass and will vibrate the most on old ground with lots of rocks.

The Bolo tine has a longer sweep reducing the effort required to dig and hence the hop on the walk behinds and the need to go over it again-which you want to do in any case to aerate the soil.

My dear father inlaw a had an original troy built with the Danish S tines and had it for over 40 years with the rope wrap pulley engine and his soil was thick powdery soil and perfect every year.

The Danish S tines were designed for weeding and he pulled rocks out of the garden every year for those forty plus years to make it perfect.

The S tines take less effort to rotate through the soil and rip quickly.


Its all matter of prefernce and how fast you want to till and how deep as the rocks are what you have to worry about more than anything.


I have been searching a bit for a rotary plow like the BCS Berta or the ones on the older Gravelys that can be attached on a rearmount three point hitch just to see who makes them or if they are being made.


A Berta rotary plow will till to 14 inches deep with a BCS or Grillo two wheel tractor as an example.

They bounce over rocks in the furrow and you stop and dig the rock out to get rid of it and thay are an easy way to remove a lot of rocks.
 
   / Opinons Gear Or Chain Drive #4  
I prefer the gear if given a choice. It seems as though it would be more durable. Thats the way I went when purchasing a tiller.
 
   / Opinons Gear Or Chain Drive
  • Thread Starter
#5  
Thanks guy's, I was thinking the same thing, no complaints on either units. I do like the the cat 1/0 hookup, keeps the lift arms away from the tires more and the attachments are a litte lighter. I'm limited to 700 lb on the 3 point. I think i'm settled on the TG 48 BX-O. I'll just have to order one.
 
   / Opinons Gear Or Chain Drive #6  
Thanks guy's, I was thinking the same thing, no complaints on either units. I do like the the cat 1/0 hookup, keeps the lift arms away from the tires more and the attachments are a litte lighter. I'm limited to 700 lb on the 3 point. I think i'm settled on the TG 48 BX-O. I'll just have to order one.

I think that's a good choice. :thumbsup:
 
   / Opinons Gear Or Chain Drive #7  
I think that's a good choice. :thumbsup:

KKR, do you know the one fundamental flaw in the design of the gear drive tillers you sell? The bolts that hold the gear cover in place are standard right hand thread. When tilling, the friction of the dirt UNSCREWS them.

Would you please slap the design engineers up side the head and ask them why they didn't use LEFT HAND threaded fasteners there?
 
 
 
Top