Hey David,
I have a Ford 1220 that I'm running a 4 foot King Kutter Brush Hog on. I really wanted to buy a 5 footer and the guys at TSC suggested I COULD probably handle it, but I went with a 4 footer. It was a better choice for an 18HP tractor.
I bought a Woods RM59 finish mower but was really lusting for a 72 inch, the 60 inch was a better choice for the 18HP Ford. It discharges the grass a mile, the 6 footer, well, I don't know, I haven't tried one yet....
This is probably a poor generalization but....
The 5 foot hog covers 20% more ground but the 4 foot hog has 20% more HP to do the same job....
I have this belief that any implement you buy at the right price, can't be a mistake, someone else will always be willing to take it off your hands!
Good Luck to you!
Curt