For my uses the rake is a worthwhile implement. I've put in a couple of
lawns now, and I don't know how I would have taken care of the thousands
of rocks and roots and branches and clumps of vegetation without a rake.
Well, you could use a dozer but then you lose all of your topsoil of course.
I turn the rake around backwards and rake into windrows, which I scoop
up with the loader and use for landfill.
I have meant to try the rake on leaves, but every year I forget. You might
try this under a big leaf tree in a pasture, but it would be too hard on a
lawn I think.
It's handy after you've cut down trees then go over the limbs with a brush
hog. There will be all sizes of woodchips and branches left over, and a few
passes with the rake will get these up pretty well.
I used to use my rake for grading my driveway, but I have since realized
that the box blade is much better for this, at least for me. No matter what
position you put the rake in, it's going to want to spread the gravel out
wider than it is, whereas the sides of the box blade will prevent the gravel
from spreading.
When I first got my rake I thought the wheels on it were invaluable. They
are sometimes, such as when you are going over bumpy ground --
without wheels the rake will rise up over the ground or dig in too deep,
depending on the angle of the tractor. However I use my wheels much
less now than I used to, not sure why I don't need them as much.
One implement that is somewhat similar in function to the rake is the
blanket harrow. I love my harrow. It's a blanket of very large chain
link, including open link posts that have a more or less aggressive action
depending on how you orient the blanket. The blanket harrow is excellent
for final seed bed preparation, for scratching grass seed into the dirt,
and for dethatching grass. I love the smell of my pastures after I drag
the blanket harrow over them a few times. It is more inclined to pull
out broad leaf plants than grass, too. It would not do your raking for
you either, at least not so well. It does pull a lot of debris out of the grass
though. Things such as rocks that do not get matted into the harrow
will be left on top of the grass, and therefore easier to clean up.
One time you will really want a rake is to smooth out topsoil that you
have deposited in small heaps with the loader. The blanket harrow
and tiller will tend to leave these heaps in place, but the rake will smooth
them right out. In my opinion the box blade is inferior for this task.