Well, thanks to you guys, this is figured out. I'm an idiot. I shouldn't have believed the guys at the parts store. They had the original bobcat filter and the new Napa filter. They never figured out that the Napa filter was built wrong or mis-labeled. They even had the wix beside it, just like in the photos, and a vernier caliper, and a book telling them what the dimensions should be! There was 3 guys trying to figure it out. I shouldn't have taken their word for it.
I also never thought to measure the threads and look them up, which would have been an easy way to check. Duhh.
Thanks and sorry for all this crap. This thread is now junk.
New Wix 51324 measures +/- 18.5mm. New Napa 1324 (misprinted?) measures +/- 22.1mm
Thanks to you all.