Buying/Pricing

   / Buying/Pricing #41  
Hehehehehe, that would be a first. I know, lets start now staying on topic. What are your thoughts Pete? By the way, what do you think Lance Armstrongs chances are of winning the yellow jersey in the Tour De (day) France, oops, there we go again, we'll start next thread, Rat...
 
   / Buying/Pricing #42  
Richard, I've never used a tractor with a synchro transmission, so naturally that would make a considerable difference. And I thought you still had an older tractor without it for baling hay. I was just curious. Most of my hay baling was with an older Oliver, so I figured to sit there with the clutch depressed and the engine running at PTO speed long enough for the baler to tie and dump a bale might be hazardous to the throw out bearing. So, when I stopped, I put it in neutral so I could let the clutch pedal out, but after dumping the bale, it was necessary to drop the RPMs to idle before trying to put it in gear again, then bring the RPMs back up to continue. That tends to slow you up and make more work, too. Of course, I didn't have that problem with the Deere PowerShift.
 
   / Buying/Pricing #43  
Since we are all posting our .02 cents worth, I might as well throw mine out.

I prefer gear over hst. My tractors at home are gear, and our tractors at work are gear. Most of our heavy equipment is HST, with some of it being gear.

From what I have observed, gear drives are better at long term even power transfer ( discing, towing, etc. ) Lets face it, even the car manufacturers know this, that is why they make auto trannies with a lock up toque converter.... the fluid medium does have some loss.
Personally shifting gears doesn't bother me.. just seems natural. An interesting observation I have made with our big JD front end loaders ( 544 series ) is that their HST trannies run very hot when you use them to tow with.
We were clearing about 40 acres and after we have it down to the dirt, with the stumps and roots out, we needed to drav harrow it to smooth it a bit before laying some geotechnical fabric. The jd 544 loader actually had the tranny overheat by towing the drag harrow after 30 minutes! Thes loader can dig in clay and load dump trucks all day fine.. but not pull constantly. We finally ended up finishing with a jd2240(gear) tractor and it drug the rest of the jobsite with no problem.

Again.. to each his own. I know many people who simply can't operate a manual transmission, or don't feel good on one... that's why they make auto's... I on the other hand don't like the power trade off.

By the way, on the HST tractors, is the hydro fluid from the same pool as the regular hydraulics? So if you bust a hydro line way out in the field, the tractor sits there?

Soundguy
<font color=blue>won't say that the hst isn't right just that a gear tractor isn't wrong either. For the extra $2k or better for an hst a guy that's on a budget or is making a decision between a bigger tractor, other equipment, etc. a geared tractor shouldn't be eliminated as a possibility. Some of us still prefer manuals and like you said there are
 
   / Buying/Pricing #44  
Bird,
I've got that Deutz that I bought for round baling. You're right though I wouldn't want to have a non-synchro transmission. That part I 100% agree with you on.
 
   / Buying/Pricing #45  
I'm wondering if "safer" is maybe not the best choice of words for a Gear/HST debate. HST is more of a convenience/ease of use item for alot of people.

Whether a tractor is a gear or hst, makes no tractor any more or less capable. Both can pull a blade, a plow, a mower, use a loader, a backhoe, etc.

There maybe be a steeper learning curve with a gear trans (not for everyone mind you), and more coordination is probably required with a gear.

As stated, there are also transmissions like the PowerReverser, which are probably almost as convenient as the HST. It's completely personal preference for the trans.

Just this past weekend, I was reminded of another reason I got a HST, I was working on our pool, and needed the tractor backed up. My options were, have my 2 year old son, 5 year old son or wife move the tractor. None of them have ever driven my tractor (I was doing something critical at the time and couldn't move it myself). Logically, I picked my wife to move the tractor. Thank God, I have a HST, as my wife has ZERO coordination. She successfully backed up 15 feet and even lowered the FEL too. 8 years ago when we were dating, I had a standard transmission car, and I thought it would be fun to teach her how to drive one. Well, she never really got the hang of it, just a complete lack of coordination. In a complete emergency, she could move a standard trans vehicle, but that's it (it wouldn't be easy). If I had a Gear tractor, I would have picked my 5 year old son to move it.

Another reason for me getting HST is I'm rather impatient. I wouldn't enjoy my tractor as much if I had to stop to change directions/speed, actually it would drive me nuts.

I was able to use a Ford 1910 gear trans for a day, backfilling some trenches. While the tractor was more than capable for this, I knew I wanted a HST when I bought my JD4300.
 
   / Buying/Pricing
  • Thread Starter
#46  
Thanks to all. Even if it gets a little heated here, I know you guys are giving me honest opinions. I know nothing about tractors, and make no bones about it when asking the dealership questions....but as I learn more, it'll be tougher to pull the wool over this kid's eyes.
As for standards vs. automatics - I own both, for different reasons. My standard is a 1992 Corvette 6 spd. I also race actively in the SkipBarber series. I drive a stick for the control, balance and precise application of power. (There is nothing like precisly sliding a 300hp stick at 40mph.....sorry had a moment there..) My 3/4 Chevy is an automatic. I plow snow up here in the great NE - something you wouldn't want to do very long with a manual, I have and have the limp to prove it. Again, a lot of automotive/mechanical experience - none with tractors. You guys have been a huge help.

The saga continues...drive the NH TC29D w/SS and compare TC33D w/o on Saturday (SS or no SS). Either way, I don't think it will be a NH. I like them, but all four cars in the driveway are bowties. Having trouble with the blue paint, heard it may go Ford again.

Have to contact the Kubota and JD dealers, but sat on a Kubota at a local closed dealership last night. They seem to be a very HD tractor - the 3010 seems to be beefier than the TC33D - but seat time will tell the tale. Thanks again. - Sean
 
   / Buying/Pricing #47  
Richard,

I will never see a plow, disc or baler on the back of any tractor I will own so I will go with your veteran savy as to the fact that the gear would be preferable here./w3tcompact/icons/smile.gif
 
   / Buying/Pricing #48  
Nope Butzkeg, safer is the word I use and think is suitable. If you recall in my post, the one thing about HST that is always in place is 4WD (providing you have 4 WD) When you shift from forward to reverse or change gears, your out of 4WD effectively and with no brakes on the front wheels it can mean whompum big trouble on steep terrain especially with a load in the front bucket. HST never disegages the front wheels from the drive train or the rear wheels for that matter and on top of that, you still have brakes that still have brand new discs because they have never been used. For years I used my synchro shift International geared manual tractor with gears, lots of gears to mow. It is precarious at best around my pond and remember, I drive this tractor sideways on 30 deg hills to the point it slides down. It still takes full concentration when using it to mow my perimeter pond weeds. It goes like this, back down in forward, clutch in, 1st gear. Gravity pulls me down, I'm in forward low in case it goes to he double LL in a hand basket. Once to the lowest point, I stand on the brakes and slowly engage the clutch. Out she comes, its work, but it works. Now for my Kubota. Back down with a simple depress on the rear of hydro pedal. Get to the bottom of where I'm mowing, foot to the front of hydro pedal sit back, relax, watch the birds and ducks and fish, enjoy life, contemplate its meaning and then willy nilly just ever so slightly with no more then 7.23 lbs of force to my right toe pull the beast up ever so safely from the perches of the pond off to do it again for another 84" worth of cutting. Theres nothing like it. I find it theraputic and calming. Peace out and nude meditation man, oh yeah, Rat...
 
   / Buying/Pricing
  • Thread Starter
#49  
Dazed...
I have been raised on a farm in WVa,I have run tractors since I was big enough to climb on one on my own.
I have driven bulldozers (John Deere 750 hydro) with hydro.I have a Sears Craftsman riding mower with hydro.
And I currently have a JD 4400 hydro...and I would not have anything else now but a hydro.
My 76 year old mother has never been able to drive a standard very well,I have never seen her drive a tractor period,but I would not hesitate to walk her out the door and put her on my JD 4400 and have her start it and drive it,because all she has to do is take her foot of the pedal to stop....The same with my 11 year old daughter.
I have about 455 hours on my tractor and I have done lots of brushoging,landscape work where all I done for all day was forward/back/forward/back.If I was having to reach for a gearshift and the clutch pedal,I would have taking me a lot longer to do the same work and I would have been a lot more tired.There is no way the average Joe can work a gear transmisson(use to a standard or not)can keep up with a person driving a hydro,not to mention the extra work of driving the standard and the wear and tear on the clutch.The syncro reverser is the next best thing,but I would still rather have the hydro.If you hade to bale off the tractor for an emergency,once your foot comes of the hydro pedal it stops.If your wife never drove a tractor,should would have fun on a hydro and probably enjoy the experiecne.
Bottom line the hydro is more user friendly than anything else out there and worth the extra $$$$ peroid. Any argument to this is asinine and bullheaded.
 
   / Buying/Pricing #50  
<font color=blue>Any argument to this is asinine and bullheaded. </font color=blue>

I wonder why words like this are more often used by unregistered types..? Dazed, there are legitimate reasons for the DT and GST models. Personally I wouldn't own one, but pay no attention to the trolls.

Pete
 
 
Top