JD 4410 vs JD 4310

[Whitnel]

Which of these two would you rather have? They look to be almost the same tractor, built around the same time.

From looking the 4410 has maybe 2 or 3 HP more and a weighs a few hundred more pounds. Lifting capacitites are about the same.

The 4410 has a 430 loader the 4310 has a 420 loader. The 4410 has 300 more hours on it at 800 vs. 500 on the 4310.

Any big differences in these tractors I should know about? Looks like they were only made for a few years.

Thanks,

 

[kennyd]

They are virtually identical machines except for the engine/horsepower. Same hydro system, frame/chassis, axles...

The 430 loader is the better one with greater lift capacity over the 420 loader, either was available for both machines.

 

[beenthere]

Agree with kennyd, and would certainly get the one with the 430 FEL. Assume both have HST.
What is the price difference?

 

[Whitnel]

1. 2002, 4410, 800 hrs, 430 loader, 5' bushhog, 5' box blade $15,900
2. 2002, 4410, 272 hrs, 420 loader $15,500
3. 2003, 4310, 537 hrs, new 300x loader $14,499

I like that the 4410 has a little more HP but like the lower hours and the new loader on the 4310. I think I could get a good bushhog and maybe a box blade for the $1,500 difference?

Thoughts,

 

[YesDeere]

That's quite the decision. My 4310 is an 04 with 580 hours on it. Great tractor no problems. Except, my 430 loader was a bit abused and is sloppy, but still works good and has plenty of lifting power. Also while using my 6 ft finish mower I sometimes wish for more hp. But all I have to do is slow down. That happens mostly when the grass is really thick in the spring.

That being said. I think I would go with door number three. Less hours. Newer loader. And would the two hp make that big of a difference? Maybe But not worth it in this comparison. Just my two cents

 

[Whitnel]

I forgot to mention they are all HST.

I am torn in each direction. If door number 2 had the 430 loader I would open that one. I need to find out how much weaker the 420 vs the 430 is.

I can't find the tractor that is the right price that is set up the way that makes me happy. I am driving myself crazy looking at tractor after tractor while I am not getting anything done at our land.

 

[RoyJackson]

Anyone of them would do nicely...the difference in hours is negligible as long as they were maintained.
However, don't wait too long to make a decision...good tractors (and the 4310's and 4410's are good tractors) sell fast.

 

[ctlguy]

Lift capacity difference between the 2 loader was only about 200#. The main difference was in the lift height approx 86" at pin vs 101"

 

[AKfish]

You might be able to find a good brush hog mower and box blade for $1,500... but, I'll bet you'll have to do some real lookin' for anything that's in half-way good condition!

Granted, they're only 5' implements but any brush-hog mower that's in good-excellent condition is likley gonna go for $1,250 or so and if the box-blade is in good shape it's gonna be $400 -- if you can find 'em!

If the tractor has been maintained well the additional hours are not that significant.

Loader, Hp and implements - I'd go with tractor #1 - condition, maintainance being equal.

AKfish

 

[Whitnel]

From the pictures tractor No. 1 looked good, it also has the quick attach system/coupler as well. The bucket looked like it still had most of the paint on it so not too much use. I emailed him today and he said it might be sold and would know for sure tomorrow. Would have looked at it already but it is 2 hours away from me and could not get there until tomorrow.