Quote:
Originally Posted by mjncad Considering aluminum costs more than steel and weight savings on a tractor seems less important than on other vehicles; it seems odd that Deere would make the housings out of this metal. |
I am dumbfounded by this design/manufacturing decision, too. It seems to
me that you need to bring a magnet with you when you get a tractor this
size. I would like to know what other tractors in this class (30+
hp, 3000+
lb naked) use all-steel or part Al. Maybe other
TBN members will post
about their CUTs. In terms of evolution, does the 4310 use Al? What about
JD's current crop, the 3xxx's?
As for fixing this, don't tell anyone, but I am going to take the axle housing
to a welder who does TIG process. Each housing new from Deere is $640.
As for analyzing this tractor, I see some mistakes like this that leave you
scratching your head (cuz it is likely cheaper to use cast iron/steel), and
some other areas where I am pleased with how they made certain parts
or subassemblies. (I just pulled apart the front wheel hub and it uses bigger
bearings and other parts vs. a similar sized Kubota I repaired a few years
ago.)