very understandable, I commend you for trying to find a compromising solution.
I wish you and the "patient" much success in the outcome. Please keep us posted on progress. I would be very much interested in the outcome as I never know what next little critter ummm.....follows Sherry home
and the information would be a great reference later down the road.
BY the way , do you have an approx time frame on how long you think this banding process should take given the size and age/ potential density of the horn?. Also looking at the pic (and not having done this procedure before) a laymen question. Shouldn't the bands be further down the horn almost touching the head?
I would think that high up will leave potential for scurs and the holes not closing up correctly.
Also when researching previously I can upon this
Band close to skull: The closer to the skull the band was seated on the horn, the more rapidly the dehorning occurred. The horn detached at the skull instead of leaving a scur of horn. I tried notching the horn base with a hand saw to hold the bands in place. It proved too difficult to saw and needless to say, the goats let us know that it hurt. I have better success using a horse hoof knife, and slicing a small V shaped notch in the sides of the horn at the junction between horn and skin.
The best solution is to apply cotton adhesive tape to the horn base and then apply the band over top, so the band is held in place by the adhesive. As well, cotton tape or duct tape over top the bands may work in holding the bands in place, by preventing the goats from rolling them off.
Clip the area: Use electric clippers to shave the front of the horn base. This allows the rubber band to grip into the skin at the horn base for a firm hold. Banding over top long hair often allows the band to roll or slide up along the hair.
http://www.nobull.net/bander/dehorningGoats.htm