Well, I think my next move is going to be the ditch and reinforced gate. If that doesn't work, it may cost me some money, but I now have three other property owners who are willing to go in on hiring an actual security company to patrol the property on weekends and one or two varying days during the week.
If I have to spend the money on professional security, there will be no "warnings". The properties will be well posted and the first offense will result in prosecution by the security firm. I think this may be the only answer to break some of the "locals". I forgot to mention that I've caught several people in the last 6 or 8 months and had a very similar thing happen. The trespassers told me that they had been hunting this land for 10 years, 20 years, 30 years, etc. I have always asked the same thing; that is "how long did you own the land?"
I always got a blank stare and a reply of something like "I ain't ever owned it." I then ask who they got permission from. Every time I've also gotten a similar answer. That is varying renditions of not ever exactly having permission.
Basically, the former owner owned several thousand acres and was almost never present. That resulted in a group (I don't know how large) of guys who have basically been trespassing for many years. The real issue is that I've been very nice and actually allowed the people to finish their hunt that day, but told them that I'm sorry, but there will be no hunting or trespassing allowed in the future. Surprisingly, rather than thanking me for not throwing them off immediately, I've been met with comments such as "I ain't gonna quit hunting here." That is when I apologized, but told them that if they insisted on that attitude, I would be left with no choice but to prosecute.
So, I feel that I've been a "nice guy" about it, but that has not worked. This is why I commented that I'm certain that my trespassers know quite well that they do not have permission and that they are trespassing. As I said, I'll try this one last time at posting the land all over again, and make it difficult to get in. If they don't get the idea, they will meet the "rent a cops" who will have orders in their contract that they have to prosecute each offense. I hate to be so hard, but I feel that I've been pushed about all I'm willing to be pushed.
My only reservations so far is that the guys I've seen from the private security force seem to be guys one step above being a thug. They all seem to want to brag about trespassers in the past who have wanted to "get rough" with them. We will have an attorney look over the contract with the security crew, but I don't think us property owners will be liable if some rough business breaks out since we will have only specified that we want all trespassers prosecuted.
Too brutal? If so, what else can I do after these people are knowingly violating the law and the wishes of the property owners? Thanks for the suggestions so far. And, yes, I do know what is suggestions that are made tongue in cheek. The only real bad situation will be if someone is trespassing and hunting when any of my 5 kids are there enjoying our property and fire gun shots towards my kids. That is a situation I am really trying to prevent at all costs, except I'm not going to be kept away from my own land to use.