buy sub soiler or rent ditch witch?

   / buy sub soiler or rent ditch witch? #1  

GaryS

Gold Member
Joined
May 29, 2004
Messages
344
Location
franklin park, pa
Tractor
Kubota L3901 & LA525
I'm installing an invisible dog fence around 7 acres of hilly land. When I went to HomeDepot to rent a DitchWitch, they talked me into renting a BlueBird BedBug. On paper, this machine was ideal - it digs a trench, lays line, and covers the trench back up. In practice, it was less than ideal. If used on a lawn, it may be perfect, but on 7 aces of field it got clogged and hit rocks. When that happened, it didn't bury the wire. The worst part is that the machine is not self propelled so I had to pull the thing over the 7 acres.

The wire installed by the BedBug is only a inch or so under ground and I seem to be having trouble with either groundhogs or deer pulling the wire out. The wire does cross a major deer traffic route and three times I've found the wire pulled out of the ground and broken.

So, I think the wire has to be buried deeper. I think 4-6" would be ideal. Would a sub soil dig a trough deep and clean enough to bury a wire? Or would I be better served by renting the DitchWitch trnacher? The DitchWitch trencher rents for $80/4 hours or $120/day and a King Kutter sub soil at TSC can be had for ~$130.

Which is better a sub soil or renting a trencher?
 
   / buy sub soiler or rent ditch witch? #2  
I would buy subsoiler and have it for next project. Cheaper in long run. if you rent? its done when ya return it.
Jim
 
   / buy sub soiler or rent ditch witch? #3  
In the past there were some posts of a modified subsoiler that was used to lay irrigation poly pipe. Nice modification and it may work very well for you.

Take a bit of time and search for it.

Dane
 
   / buy sub soiler or rent ditch witch? #5  
wouldnt a subsoiler lay it too deep?
 
   / buy sub soiler or rent ditch witch? #6  
You control the depth with the 3 pt hitch. Should be no problem....
 
   / buy sub soiler or rent ditch witch?
  • Thread Starter
#7  
Tom_Veatch said:
Laying_Pipe shows how one guy laid some Poly Pipe.

Awesome! I just called TSC and ordered a sub soiler. I'll have it next Wednesday and wll have wire in the ground on Saturday (at least that's the plan!)
 
   / buy sub soiler or rent ditch witch? #8  
I saved a reference to that thread because I had in mind the exact application you have. However, I'm finding that I have more trouble with neighborhood dogs invading my ground than I do with my dog straying. And I ain't about to buy collars and train every durn stray dog in the township. So, I haven't laid one of those fences yet. (Still trying to get the wife to accept the idea of a "real" fence. I've already bought the PHD.)
 
   / buy sub soiler or rent ditch witch? #9  
Subsoiler...
David from jax
 
   / buy sub soiler or rent ditch witch? #10  
that was the post that I was thinking of in my reply as well.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

DigMaster DM-F20 Forklift (A43476)
DigMaster DM-F20...
2018 John Deere 652R 52in Stand-On Mower (A46684)
2018 John Deere...
2018 Kubota RTVX1140 (A47307)
2018 Kubota...
2017 Chevrolet Impala Sedan (A46684)
2017 Chevrolet...
2015 KENWORTH T370 QUINT AXLE DUMP TRUCK (A45678)
2015 KENWORTH T370...
Swict 96in Fork Extensions (A46683)
Swict 96in Fork...
 
Top