Just how strong is a ROPS?

   / Just how strong is a ROPS? #1  

JayC

Veteran Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2001
Messages
2,242
Location
MI's Thumb
As I was sitting here looking over a 4000 TEN series brochure, there was a little picture of a 4000 TEN series tractor that showed the protective area of the ROPS. I started to wonder how strong the ROPS really was. Will the ROPS keep from caving in, in the event of a roll over if the rear tires are loaded or lots of weight on the 3PH or wheel weights or a combination of the three? I know the ROPS is designed to keep the machine weight from squashing you in the event of a roll over, but what about any additional weight attached to the tractor?
 
   / Just how strong is a ROPS? #2  
That's a good question.

I would think if your tractor manual states that loading of tires is OK, then the ROPS should be designed to carry that weight.

Thinking further, if the 3PH is designed to lift XXX lbs of weight, then the ROPS should be able to support that amount of weight as well in a roll over, shouldn't it?

Back flip is a seperate issue I suppose.

Doubt that there are any published numbers on the rops, just like there don't seem to be any on the degree of side slope where the tractor will tip...
 
   / Just how strong is a ROPS? #3  
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( Doubt that there are any published numbers on the rops, just like there don't seem to be any on the degree of side slope where the tractor will tip... )</font>

No but there a standard that all ROPS need to comply with.

Andy
 
   / Just how strong is a ROPS? #4  
i beleive the rops is strong enough to handel , filled tires or wheel weights or any implement that the particular tractor could handel on the 3 PT. if not they would open themselves up to mega lawsuits. Usually if and when a tractor rolls it does it quite slowly, not like dropping it off a 10 story building.
 
   / Just how strong is a ROPS? #5  
<font color="blue"> No but there a standard that all ROPS need to comply with. </font>

Andy,

Where might one find that standard? I would imagine OSHA has one...but not sure it that would apply to CUTs.

Does one standard apply to all manufacturers of CUTs?

I have not got a clue, but would like to read that standard... /forums/images/graemlins/cool.gif
 
   / Just how strong is a ROPS? #6  
Please note that any standards that you read do not take into account any holes that are drilled into the ROPS. /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif
 
   / Just how strong is a ROPS? #7  
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( That's a good question.)</font>

I want you all to take note as to who was the first one to answer this questions?? /forums/images/graemlins/confused.gif

Henro you continue to amaze us /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif
 
   / Just how strong is a ROPS? #8  
</font><font color="blue" class="small">(
Does one standard apply to all manufacturers of CUTs?

I have not got a clue, but would like to read that standard... /forums/images/graemlins/cool.gif )</font>

A quick Google search using ASTM ROPS turned up hundreds of hits. A lot of CSA Canadian Standards and a bunch of US. Many allow either standard to be used and I think you'll find most if not all comply to both. the standards specify design standards and testing. They also specify permanent marking of standards met. One thing that also is required is that every ROPS be serialized. So Henro the one you drilled can be traced /forums/images/graemlins/cool.gif

16.21 Protective structures

(1) Operators of mobile equipment must be protected against falling, flying or intruding objects or material by means of suitable cabs, screens, grills, shields, deflectors, guards or structures.

(2) The means of protection must meet the requirements of the following applicable standard:

(a) WCB Standard -- G601, Standard for Log Loader and Log Yarder Backstops;

(b) WCB Standard -- G602, Standard for Log Loader and Log Yarder Raised Cabs;

(c) WCB Standard -- G603, Standard for Log Loader and Log Yarder Window Guards;

(d) WCB Standard -- G604, Standard for Light-Duty Screen Guards for Off-Highway Equipment;

(e) WCB Standard -- G605, Standard for Mobile Equipment Half-Doors;

(f) WCB Standard -- G607, Standard for Medium Duty Screen Guards -- Front End Log Loader;

(g) WCB Standard -- G608, Standard for Mobile Equipment Roof Structures -- Heavy Duty;

(h) WCB Standard -- G609, Standard for Mobile Equipment Roof Structures -- Light Duty;

(i) Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) Recommended Practice J231 JAN81, Minimum Performance Criteria for Falling Object Protective Structure (FOPS);

(j) Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) Standard J1043 SEP87, Performance Criteria for Falling Object Protective Structure (FOPS) for Industrial Machines;

(k) ISO Standard 3449:1992, Earth-Moving Machinery -- Falling-Object Protective Structures -- Laboratory Tests and Performance Requirements;

(l) Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) Recommended Practice J1084 APR80, Operator Protective Structure Performance Criteria for Certain Forestry Equipment;

(m) Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) Recommended Practice J1356 FEB88, Performance Criteria for Falling Object Guards for Excavators.

(3) A worker must not remain in the cab of a vehicle while loads are elevated over the cab unless the cab is protected by an adequate overhead guard.

       [Amended by B.C. Reg. 312/2003, effective October 29, 2003.]
* See also section 4.4 of the OHS Regulation.

Note: Information on the selection of guarding for mobile equipment used in various applications is provided in the WCB publication Standards for Operator Protective Structures (OPS).


16.22 Rollover protective structures

(1) The following types of mobile equipment, weighing 700 kg (1 500 lbs) or more, must have rollover protective structures (ROPS):

(a) crawler tractors, loaders and skidders;

(b) wheel tractors, dozers, loaders and skidders;

(c) motor graders;

(d) self-propelled wheel scrapers;

(e) compactors/rollers;

(f) self-propelled rock drills moved by an on-board operator;

(g) wheeled trenchers manufactured after January 1, 1999;

(h) pipe layers or side boom tractors manufactured after January 1, 2000.

(2) The board may require a ROPS to be installed on any mobile equipment if the design of the equipment or circumstances of use indicate the need.

(3) Mobile equipment listed in subsection (1) may be used without a ROPS if

(a) the equipment operates in a specific location where there is no significant hazard of rollover, and

(b) the surface in the area of operation is maintained free of ground irregularities which might cause a rollover.

Note: Where circumstances render compliance with the requirement for ROPS impracticable, alternative proposals designed to provide equivalent protection to workers may be submitted to the board for consideration.


16.23 ROPS standards

A ROPS must meet the requirements of one of the following applicable standards:

(a) CSA Standard B352.0-95, Rollover Protective Structures (ROPS) for Agricultural, Construction, Earthmoving, Forestry, Industrial, and Mining Machines -- Part 1: General Requirements, and

(i) CSA Standard B352.1-95, Rollover Protective Structures (ROPS) for Agricultural, Construction, Earthmoving, Forestry, Industrial, and Mining Machines -- Part 2: Testing Requirements for ROPS on Agricultural Tractors, or

(ii) CSA Standard B352.2-95, Rollover Protective Structures (ROPS) for Agricultural, Construction, Earthmoving, Forestry, Industrial, and Mining Machines -- Part 3: Testing Requirements for ROPS on Construction, Earthmoving, Forestry, Industrial, and Mining Machines;

(b) Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) Standard J1040 MAY94, Performance Criteria for Rollover Protective Structures (ROPS) for Construction, Earthmoving, Forestry, and Mining Machines;

(c) ISO Standard 3471: 1994, Earth-moving Machinery -- Rollover Protective Structures -- Laboratory Tests and Performance Requirements.

(d) Repealed. [B.C. Reg. 312/2003, effective October 29, 2003.]
* See section 4.4 of the OHS Regulation.

Note: Clause 6 of CSA Standard B352-M80, Rollover Protective Structures (ROPS) for Agricultural, Construction, Earthmoving, Forestry, Industrial and Mining Machines is a standard acceptable to the board under section 4.4(2) for the design of a ROPS for a one-of-a-kind machine.

       [Note revised October 29, 2003.]


16.24 ROPS certification

(1) A ROPS must be certified by the ROPS manufacturer or a professional engineer as meeting a standard specified in section 16.23.

(2) Any addition, modification, welding or cutting on a ROPS must be done in accordance with the instructions of and be recertified by the ROPS manufacturer or a professional engineer.


16.25 ROPS identification

(1) The following information must be permanently marked upon a ROPS:

(a) the name and address of the manufacturer or the professional engineer who certified the ROPS;

(b) the model number or other effective means of identifying the machine for which the ROPS was designed;

(c) the serial number or other unique means of identifying the ROPS;

(d) the maximum weight of the machine for which the ROPS was designed;

(e) the standard to which the ROPS conforms.

(2) Modified ROPS must be permanently marked with the following information:

(a) an identification of the modifications effected;

(b) the date of recertification;

(c) the name and address of the recertifying engineer.


16.26 Effects of ROPS on visibility

ROPS and other structures required by this Part for the protection of the operator must be designed and installed to provide an adequate view for the operator to safely use the machine.
 
   / Just how strong is a ROPS? #9  
Henro

If you really want to read a standard heres a link to "buy" the ISO standard.

ISO 3741
ISO 3471:1994
Earth-moving machinery -- Roll-over protective structures -- Laboratory tests and performance requirements

Abstract
Establishes a consistent and reproducible means of evaluating the load-carrying characteristics of roll-over protective structures under static loading, and prescribes performance requirements for a representative specimen under such loading. Applies to the following seated design operator-controlled machines as defined in ISO 6165: crawler tractors and loaders, graders, wheeled loaders and wheeled tractors, wheeled industrial tractors, the tractor portion (prime mover) of tractor scrapers, water wagons, etc., rollers and compactors, rigid frame dumpers.

Have fun, maybe with a little searching you'll find a free one.

Andy
 
   / Just how strong is a ROPS? #10  
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( Usually if and when a tractor rolls it does it quite slowly, not like dropping it off a 10 story building. )</font> When I was in grade school I saw a tractor roll over and the driver run over by the mower. That tractor went over in the ditch in about 2 seconds. John
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2012 Kenworth T370 4x4 Terex Hi-Ranger 5TC-55 55ft Bucket Truck (A46683)
2012 Kenworth T370...
H&S 2606 Manure Spreader (A49251)
H&S 2606 Manure...
TPM 16 Mini Excavator (A49251)
TPM 16 Mini...
Bale Spear (A49251)
Bale Spear (A49251)
Stump Grapple (A49251)
Stump Grapple (A49251)
Crown PE4000-60 Riding Jack (A49251)
Crown PE4000-60...
 
Top