radman1 said:
Would it be simpler to just go electric and run it off the battery? How much pulling power do hydraulic winches have? Are the hydraulic ones cheaper?
I own one electric 2000lb Warn Winch, one electric 2500lb Warn winch, one electric 12,000lb Warn winch, one electric 8000lb Ramsey winch and one hydraulic Mile Marker 10,500lb winch.
The pulling power of the winch is determined in it's construction and has nothing to do with hydraulic or electric.
Hydraulic winches and electric winches are similarly priced.
Electric winches require a high output alternator and/or dual batteries if you are going to do long, hard, repeated pulls. They develop a lot of heat and use huge amounts of amperage draw during these pulls.
Hydraulic winches require the appropriate hydraulic pressure and flow rate. They will pull all day with little heat buildup or hydraulic stress on your tractor's system.
If you are creating a system to use for long pulls and repeated pulls I would suggest hydraulic. If you are creating a system for occassional pulls of moderate or short duration, go electric.