Soundguy
Old Timer
- Joined
- Mar 11, 2002
- Messages
- 52,238
- Location
- Central florida
- Tractor
- RK 55HC,ym1700, NH7610S, Ford 8N, 2N, NAA, 660, 850 x2, 541, 950, 941D, 951, 2000, 3000, 4000, 4600, 5000, 740, IH 'C' 'H', CUB, John Deere 'B', allis 'G', case VAC
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( My take on that is that 30W oil is the cheapest thing the manufacturers can pour in, for the purpose of preservation during shipment. Sorta like cosmoline on new guns )</font>
I agree completely.. except.. that their factory should produce a finished product. There is no reason why they should go to the expense to produce a tractor.. then pour the absolute cheapes fluid in it they can. This same discussion went on in the yanmar sub a while back. Someone asked about tranny oil, and a dealer mentioned that the factory ( exporter? ) said ATF was fine.. I pointed out that the tranny and rear end are a common sump.. and I questioned whethere tranny fluid would be a good rear final drive lube.. since virtually NO other equipment manufacturer uses it that way...And that is what it boiled down to.. cheapest fluid they could ship it with.. I signed off that thread with a warning to check their imports in case baby oil or cooking oil ever went on sale.. as that is probably what would get shipped out.. using that 'pass the buck' logic.
One point though.. cosmo on guns is for storage.. not lubrication... If someone shipped a gun in vasolene to save a buck.. that would be a closer analogy. I expect that tractor to roll of fthe line and be work ready.. all fluids inclusive.
I see domestic tractors arive at 'big-3' dealers and they drive them of fthe truck.. so they aren't shipped dry. I'm guessing that's the same oil the purchaser gets when he buys the tractor...
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( So I believe what you've heard comes from self-importers )</font>
What I've heard comes from right here.. this very sub.. search the archives.. many specific threads about the oils being too thick for the screen.. plus many other cheap out the door shortcuts.. questionable radiator fluid, and or batteries.
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( The defects you see may very well be as a result of the cottage industry approach; many jobbers providing a common part or casting, no two of which are ever exactly the same )</font>
I also believe that to be true. Lots of hand fitting.. and many parts sources assembled and sold as spec'd. I guess if you have lotsa rice, labor and not much else.. that's what you get... lots of otherwise unskilled labor making parts that come off production equipment that isn't altogether exact... thus providing parts that are almost unique.. etc.
( not kicking them for this... just agreeing verbosely.. ya work with what ya got...)
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( And it's much apparently simpler for them to cast iron and steel than it is to stamp steel )</font>
Again.. I agree. I've even bought asian produced aftermarket parts for my older domestic tractors.. in many cases the part being replaced will have been oem stamped steel or machined billet.. etc.. and will come in as some sort of cast metal.. etc.
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( This is just a small example of why I recommend potential owners buy more (Chinese) horsepower than they think they'll ever need
)</font>
Agree.. again.. and here's another reason to get more chineese hp.. think of it like this. Compair a higher quality brand 'x' tractor and a chineese tractor of same stats.. work both at max usage.. or even overtax them. My bet is that the one built to higher tolerance standards.. and using superior materials will live longer. Take that same tractor and instead compair it to a chineese one 1.5 times as big, and theat cureve may well level out... while the smaller unit is stillat max usage.. the chineese one may be bumped back down into regular use.. in which case.. should last longer..
Like you said.. its all relative.. everyones really buying the same amount of tractor per dollar.. the chineese ones are just less expen$ive per unit...
/forums/images/graemlins/tongue.gif
Soundguy
I agree completely.. except.. that their factory should produce a finished product. There is no reason why they should go to the expense to produce a tractor.. then pour the absolute cheapes fluid in it they can. This same discussion went on in the yanmar sub a while back. Someone asked about tranny oil, and a dealer mentioned that the factory ( exporter? ) said ATF was fine.. I pointed out that the tranny and rear end are a common sump.. and I questioned whethere tranny fluid would be a good rear final drive lube.. since virtually NO other equipment manufacturer uses it that way...And that is what it boiled down to.. cheapest fluid they could ship it with.. I signed off that thread with a warning to check their imports in case baby oil or cooking oil ever went on sale.. as that is probably what would get shipped out.. using that 'pass the buck' logic.
One point though.. cosmo on guns is for storage.. not lubrication... If someone shipped a gun in vasolene to save a buck.. that would be a closer analogy. I expect that tractor to roll of fthe line and be work ready.. all fluids inclusive.
I see domestic tractors arive at 'big-3' dealers and they drive them of fthe truck.. so they aren't shipped dry. I'm guessing that's the same oil the purchaser gets when he buys the tractor...
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( So I believe what you've heard comes from self-importers )</font>
What I've heard comes from right here.. this very sub.. search the archives.. many specific threads about the oils being too thick for the screen.. plus many other cheap out the door shortcuts.. questionable radiator fluid, and or batteries.
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( The defects you see may very well be as a result of the cottage industry approach; many jobbers providing a common part or casting, no two of which are ever exactly the same )</font>
I also believe that to be true. Lots of hand fitting.. and many parts sources assembled and sold as spec'd. I guess if you have lotsa rice, labor and not much else.. that's what you get... lots of otherwise unskilled labor making parts that come off production equipment that isn't altogether exact... thus providing parts that are almost unique.. etc.
( not kicking them for this... just agreeing verbosely.. ya work with what ya got...)
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( And it's much apparently simpler for them to cast iron and steel than it is to stamp steel )</font>
Again.. I agree. I've even bought asian produced aftermarket parts for my older domestic tractors.. in many cases the part being replaced will have been oem stamped steel or machined billet.. etc.. and will come in as some sort of cast metal.. etc.
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( This is just a small example of why I recommend potential owners buy more (Chinese) horsepower than they think they'll ever need
)</font>
Agree.. again.. and here's another reason to get more chineese hp.. think of it like this. Compair a higher quality brand 'x' tractor and a chineese tractor of same stats.. work both at max usage.. or even overtax them. My bet is that the one built to higher tolerance standards.. and using superior materials will live longer. Take that same tractor and instead compair it to a chineese one 1.5 times as big, and theat cureve may well level out... while the smaller unit is stillat max usage.. the chineese one may be bumped back down into regular use.. in which case.. should last longer..
Like you said.. its all relative.. everyones really buying the same amount of tractor per dollar.. the chineese ones are just less expen$ive per unit...
/forums/images/graemlins/tongue.gif
Soundguy