I don't have experience with those specific models, but after picking up an Erskine rear pull snowblower last year, I'll NEVER go back to a rear push model. I also have an open station tractor, so this may not be relative, but with the rear push the snowblower would often blow snow back in my face as I was blowing backwards. With the rear pull, I have not had this problem yet. That said, I still want a cab lol, however this is just one of the many advantages of the rear pull.