I have a RatchetRake and had a Landscape rake. The RatchetRake is best for final clean up of lose debris and for leveling out loose dirt for grass seeding. I'm not saying the RatchetRake wouldn't do it but the fine teeth are close to the ground and when you got a volume of debris, it would roll over it and it does have to be done in reverse. The forward teeth are for clearing out brush. The Landscape rake, in my opinion, would be your best implement for what you say needs to be done. Sometimes you/we have to get off our tractors, that's just life but I believe there would be less hand work with the Landscape Rake.