"Real World" diesel fuel mileage on Duramax

   / "Real World" diesel fuel mileage on Duramax #51  
True, that is why as a "semi-current" and former competitive cyclist, I went straight for the wheels when trying to cut weight off my bike. But, true to fashion, aero trumps weight. Anyone who has towed notices this too with truck fuel economy. Give me a 10000# load that rides low on the trailer than a 7000# load that sits out of the tailgate slipstream any time.

John M
 
   / "Real World" diesel fuel mileage on Duramax
  • Thread Starter
#52  
After about a week with my truck, I'd like to say that the fuel mileage question is........... well, I'm still not sure.

I thought mileage was great until I filled up the tank and reset the DIC. Then mileage seemed to be not too good. Far lower than I was expecting. Around town with sporadic freeway driving, I was getting like 14, maybe less. So I reset it again before taking off yesterday and found mileage terrible. Like my H2 terrible. WTH?? On the trip home, I decided to reset as I entered the freeway. Mileage not good.... but wait. After about 2 miles in, economy suddenly improved to where the DIC read 19.1 when I exited the freeway. But it dropped to about 17.5 by the time I pulled into my driveway. This morning, I drove to work again and mileage steadily dropped again. Read 14 by the time I got home. Frustrated, I went to dinner (15 miles away) and trying to get a feel at least of the freeway fuel economy, I reset the DIC again (GM used to have instant fuel mileage but now only have "average" on the truck DIC's). This time, fuel mileage seemed great. Mileage steadily climbed and read 22.3mpg as I exited the freeway. After some around town driving, it was still reading 20.3 by the time I hit the freeway again. By the time I got home, it was 22mpg average again.

In conclusion, I'm left scratching my head. I'm thinking that at some point, there could've been a regen cycle without me knowing it. I was under the impression that I would know when it happens, like a DIC notice or something. I don't recall seeing any alert and maybe a regen cycle occured, maybe not. Still unsure. My feeling thus far is that this truck gets GREAT fuel mileage driven on the freeway but city driving is nothing to write home about. Perhaps as I get more used to the truck, I'll have a better idea and maybe I'll get a "feel" of when regen is occuring.

I've also learned something new about the DEF fluid. The sales person told me that the large tank I see under the truck was fluid that needs to be changed... usually at the same time the oil is changed. But I now know from reading the manual that it's not like that at all. Rather the fluid is consumed by the truck via injection into the exhaust and needs to be replenished from time/time. You would think the the salesperson would know what he's talking about so I'm a little disappointed of who the dealerships hire. Ironically, this guy seemed more knowledgeable than the salespersons I spoke to in 2 other dealerships. On those two, I clearly knew more about the trucks than them. One guy at a chevy dealer tried to sell me a used superduty on his lot -- WTF?? Why would I go to Chevy to buy a used Ford? Anyhow, this new regen, and DEF thing is entirely new to me. My old diesel tow trucks never had any such thing. The regen feature injecting fuel into the exhaust -- seems almost like throwing money out the window. As I understand it, the exhaust needs to be "HOT" for faster regen cycle. The engineers have stated that the cycle is more efficient when the engine is loaded. Perhaps by "babying" the motor in city driving, trying to extract mileage, I was inadvertently "extending" the regen cycle. Heck, if the computer is just going to "throw" fuel into the exhaust, I might as well be the one doing it so next time I am aware of the cycle occuring, I'm going to drive more aggressively since if mileage is going to suffer, I might as well get the most out of it and the more aggressive use might actually shorten the cycle. Perhaps my line of thinking is way out there.... anyone else have any experience with this?

About the wheels -- I believe that the entire assembly is the same diameter whichever wheel is chosen. This is probably the most expensive wheel option, although I prefer the looks of the 18" forged wheel than this 20" forged wheel. I don't think the choice of these wheels have any affect on fuel mileage.

One week in and still learning. One thing that I do know, however. Power and braking is phenomenal. Reminds me of my corvette. I can pass other cars at will and it pulls crazy. Of course the instant drop in economy quickly reminds me "don't do that." Braking feels like there is tremendous excess capacity. At no time do I feel uncomforable with the brakes. It's fun watching and challenging myself to maximize the fuel mileage right now but at some point, I probably won't care and the only thing I will care about is how good it accelerates and stops.

I hear some guys whining about the steering shaft issue and allison tranny fluid lines leaking. Well, after owning many GM trucks/SUV's over the last decade, I am familiar with the steering issue which is really just a lubrication issue and not a safety issue. Annoying yes, and they replaced it twice on my Avalanche but the last time they replaced that shaft with the updated parts -- the noise never returned. Hopefully, that issue has been corrected for good in these 2012's. Regarding the tranny fluid lines leaking issue.... This is news to me and I didn't know about this tendency before deciding to buy this truck. I do live in an area with mediteranean climate and weather is very moderate so this probably won't be an issue for me. But if that is the biggest beef with this truck, heck, I'll take that any day of the week. We bought a brand new Dodge Ram in 2003 that needed 3 rear axle rebuilds in 36,000 miles so annoying issues can be far worse than leaking tranny lines. Needless to say, I traded in that Dodge for my 2003 Silverado and never purchased another Dodge product. That dealer treated me wrong and I never forgot.
 
   / "Real World" diesel fuel mileage on Duramax #53  
I have heard the DIC called a lie-o-meter, ect. I would stick with proven math when you fill up. Just note the millage and then do the math with the gallons put in.

As for MPG, my neighbor gets 13/14 mpg week in and out in his Dmax. That is just what it is. On the highway on a trip he can do 19/21 mpg depending on how he drives it.

This is for a Crew Cab 4x4 with 86,000 miles. He has also watched every gallon put into it. He is self employeed so its for taxes but he says he has driven it like there is a egg on the gas pedal and also driven it like he stole it and the difference is negligible.

Chris
 
   / "Real World" diesel fuel mileage on Duramax #54  
I think you are paying too much attention to the MPG for a truck that is still being broken in. Put a couple thousand miles on it and then see what it does after that.

I've also learned something new about the DEF fluid. The sales person told me that the large tank I see under the truck was fluid that needs to be changed...

You are correct, it consumes the DEF. The DIC will inform you when it gets low so you know to fill it back up, and if it gets empty the truck will eventually go into a limp mode, which is mandated by the EPA, and you won't be able to go highway speed. See the instruction manual for details.

Also you should read the maintenance schedule in the duramax manual. There is some breaking-in stuff you should be aware of, in particular, the Allison transmission is supposed to have the external filter changed at 500mi (?) to remove anything that accumulates during break-in.

Some guys say if you have the locking rear axle, you shouldn't do extended highway driving during the first few hundred miles also, because it needs to break-in and if it doesn't do so before you start taking highway trips with it, the gears can overheat. This might be why you went through some rear ends in your Dodge?
 
   / "Real World" diesel fuel mileage on Duramax #55  
Yep, external tranny filter must be changed at 500 miles to keep the warranty valid on the Allison.

Chris
 
   / "Real World" diesel fuel mileage on Duramax #56  
2002 Duramax with 220,000+ miles now. I bought new. Put 265/75/16 LTX MS tires on it with 500 miles on the odometer....and I've gone through 3 sets of those tires. The last set I went to 285/75/16 BFGoodrich AT...and my mileage went down a little.

I have gotten 20.5 MPG three different times in commutes in the Pittsburgh area, and that is with a transfer tank included...about 45 gals of diesel on each fill and calculation. BUT that was driving like the old man I am, 50-60 mph too.

When newer I got about 18.5 on the road cruise 70mph...actually about 72 corrected. I think the diesel blend has changed and I don't get quite as good. With these 285's on a trip from Illinois to Texas recently I got 17.8 mpg...and that's cruise at 70, but actually 75 corrected. I'm going back to 265s with the next set. I had a 5th wheel Holiday Rambler. The worse I saw with a bad headwind was 7.5 mpg. More Typically I saw 10.5 pulling around 65 mph. It also pulled better with the 265s. If I get in a hurry....the mileage goes down QUICK.

I'll die with this truck unless it's wrecked or something. BUT with diesel at $4.05 and counting, I drive it only when I have to now. From what I'm read the newer trucks don't do as well.
 
   / "Real World" diesel fuel mileage on Duramax #57  
I have an 01 and I get 17 around town and 22 on the road.
 
   / "Real World" diesel fuel mileage on Duramax
  • Thread Starter
#58  
Also you should read the maintenance schedule in the duramax manual. There is some breaking-in stuff you should be aware of, in particular, the Allison transmission is supposed to have the external filter changed at 500mi (?) to remove anything that accumulates during break-in.

Some guys say if you have the locking rear axle, you shouldn't do extended highway driving during the first few hundred miles also, because it needs to break-in and if it doesn't do so before you start taking highway trips with it, the gears can overheat. This might be why you went through some rear ends in your Dodge?

Thanks for the info on the transmission. I didn't know that and the sales person never mentioned a thing. It already has 320 miles on it, so I would probably eclipse the 500 mile mark and not know it if you guys didn't tell me.

Regarding the axle and the Dodge: Since you ask, let me tell the story. New Dodge ram comes out -- bold new big rig look, a fresh change from all the other P/U's. So we take a chance. Buy the Ram. No, it's not a work truck. It's a commuter -- drive kids to school, that type of thing. No long distance driving at all. No locking axle. Just plain jane Dodge ram. Window cranks, manual transmission and all. The only option of any significance was the AC. At the dealership, they pushed hard to sell their extended warranty while signing papers. Tell me that if we don't use it, we get all our money back. $2,5000, like idiots under the pressure, we bought it hook line and sinker.

12,000 miles mark, the truck makes a grinding noise. Sounds like truck is dragging a chain. Bring to dealer and they say axle bearings are shot (not the gears). Tell me MY fault because I didn't change differential fluid. I say WTF, make a ruckus and tell them that in all my years of buying vehicles, NEVER had a the differential go out at 12K miles, nor are we supposed to change differential fluid at such intervals. They point to owners manual which states during severe duty use.... but I say, listen: this is NOT a work truck. It looks immaculate. There is a baby seat attached to the rear seat and not a spec of dust in it. they begrudingly performed the warranty service.

23K miles, same noise comes back. I bring it in.... they tell me NOPE not covered since it's already 23k miles and I didn't change the differential fluid. I say, what? HOW do you know I never changed the fluid. In fact, YOU guys rebuilt the differential at 12K miles. Are you saying YOU put the old fluid back in it? They begrudgingly rebuilt the differential again.

Well, 34k miles, noise sounds like it's coming back. We decided there is no way that we were going to own a truck that needs a rebuilt axle every 12k miles. And due to how the dealer treated us the last 2 times, we had enough and weren't going to take a chance that we were going to be able to service the axle every time it goes bad. We were going to get rid of the truck and cash in our extended warranty. We figured since the factory bumper to bumper warranty had not yet expired, the extended warranty never kicked in, and therefore, we were due our original purchase amount back since we never used it. WRONG. We went in, spoke with everyone and their position was that even though the bumper to bumper did not term out yet, the extended warranty was always in effect so we couldn't get our money back. I say how is that possible? They say because the extended warranty offered rental car coverage when vehicle is being repaired. I reminded them that at no time did I ever accepted a rental car. They said doesn't matter... the coverage was there. So even though the extended warranty did not kick in yet, and I filed NO claims of any kind, I was NOT entitled to my money back. In other words, they told me a BALD FACED LIE when they pushed us to buy the extended warranty. I, my wife, and my kids all heard them tell us this lie when we bought this vehicle as we were all there. At this point, I tell them fine, they can treat us like sh*t, but from this point forward, I will announce to all my family (we have a huge family) all my friends and acquaintences about my experience and we will NEVER ever buy another dodge product again. If they don't value their customers, then they will have none.

At that point, we traded in the Dodge for a 3/4 ton Silverado. Since that Dodge, we have owned 2 tahoes, a Hummer H2, an Avalanche, a Lincoln LS, a Cadillac SRX, and now this new 2500HD. I have never ever before that Dodge, had a differential go out on any vehicle, and afterwards, never ever had any differential issues with anything else either. Except for the tranny going out on the first Tahoe at 50k, all the other vehicles so far have been completely trouble free. We forgot about the Dodge and moved on. But we never forgot. Since that time, we have had many people ask our opinions when buying new vehicles and after hearing our story, decided to buy something else. There is no telling how many sales Dodge lost because of our experience, but I think it would be at least several sales and maybe more. My memory is long. I will never forget how Dodge treated us, and how they made us justify the warranty claims like we were bad guys, and how they tried to slither out of them. It wasn't the first new vehicle we owned and every warranty service up to then was easy as pie. Needless to say, we will never buy another Dodge and will continue to lobby our friends against them.

I still buy American as I feel like if I'm going to throw money at a car, might as well feed someone here in the USA, but it would either be a GM or a Ford. Dodge doesn't exist anymore as far as I'm concerned.

On a side note: At the time I traded in my Dodge, I asked a friend of mine who was a tech at the BMW what's up with the rear ends going out. Seems he read something about Dana (the manufacturer of the rear end?) having some tooling issues with the 1/2 ton differentials. Seems to make sense since differentials were in my experience up to that point, rather bulletproof low maintenance components in normal non-work-vehicle environments. I figure an axle shaft might not be straight or something or the bearings not heavy duty enough for the applications. Never had a differential need rebuilding once in a vehicles lifetime, much less 3 times in 36k miles. Wait, I take that back -- I had a vette once with 100k miles having a high pitched whine but nothing like the chain dragging sound of the Dodge.

Anyhow, that's the story and why I will NEVER buy another Dodge again, no matter how good a product review they will get, the people behind the product is part of the package.
 
   / "Real World" diesel fuel mileage on Duramax #59  
Here is a pic of my 01.
 

Attachments

  • ForumRunner_20120315_071153.png
    ForumRunner_20120315_071153.png
    660 KB · Views: 225
   / "Real World" diesel fuel mileage on Duramax #60  
Superduper said:
Anyhow, that's the story and why I will NEVER buy another Dodge again, no matter how good a product review they will get, the people behind the product is part of the package.
Taking your problems out on Dodge is dumb in this case. You got a bad truck, it happens and unfortunately you had a bad dealer on top of that. It sounds like a mis-aligned axle and differential that continued to cause problems. Stuff like that should be found by a good mechanic, after the second time I would have contacted a rep at Chrysler. The dealer was the problem here, not the manufacturer.

Back to the question of Duramax mpgs...
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

Kenmore KLFC015MWD0 Deep Freezer (A53117)
Kenmore...
(INOP) CATERPILLAR IT-38G LOADER (A51247)
(INOP) CATERPILLAR...
CAT 973 (A47384)
CAT 973 (A47384)
2021 BOBCAT T450 SKID STEER (A51246)
2021 BOBCAT T450...
PALLET OF EXTENSION CORDS AND AIR HOSES (A53843)
PALLET OF...
2022 LOAD TRAIL 8' X 24' TRAILER (A51247)
2022 LOAD TRAIL 8'...
 
Top