jejeosborne
Veteran Member
I have a 2011 with 3.55 gears and a 3.5L. Towing 10,000 pounds and it'll downshift to 5th sometimes 4th gear on hills (consider Minnesota is relatively flatish). Power is ample. Locking out 5th gear gives me a final drive shorter than the option 3.73 final drive and so I see no point in getting a short gear version.
I too have a 2011 ecoboost but have the 3.73 max tow option. I have two friends with the 3.55 rear and we get the same gas mileage because all our driving is mixed. My suggestion is if you drive 75% highway, get the 3.55. Otherwise get the 3.73. My 3.73 shifts up to the higher gears quicker in town allowing the torque converter to lock sooner. Also, I would rather have the gear reduction done in the larger, better supported gears in the rear end vs the smaller gears in the Trans which also removes some stress in the driveshaft supports and u-joints. You will also enjoy fewer downshifts while towing.