I am one of those in the "anecdotal" camp. Didn't read it on the internet. Did not study chemistry related to petroleum and ethanol. I have worked on IC devices since I was 10, which was appx 45 years ago. So no, my mechanic. nor any dealer, told me anything. ALL, of my gasoline engine devices, that is all, not some, of which there are 6 Cars/Trucks, 8 Gas engines below 27HP and 4, 2-strokes of varying CC, run poorly or not at all, when I use ethanol laced fuel. I've got a 4-cycle Trimmer, and a 2-stroke Chainsaw that will not start when using ethanol laced fuel. Others that I can eventually get running, but stall, run roughly, etc. My UTV takes 2-3 x's longer to start and sputters along, change fuel, immediately fires up runs smooth (Honda V-Twin) (and don't even get me started about what it does to the 83 Yamaha 750 Triple).
2008 Jeep Commander 4.7, loses 3 mpg and hates the cold when forced to used E10. Change the fuel, problem solved.
1992 Ford F250 460, hates the stuff - flat out.
Truth being, by using various additions to my fuel of Stabil, or Redline, or Lucas, et al - and some satisfactory performance can be had with the dreaded e10. But really, the gas is NEW, why should I have to modify it?
Bottom line, by changing nothing but the fuel, all of these issues disappear. Anecdotal? Un-scientific? Perhaps. Fact? Absolutely.
That's my story, YMMV.
Max