Oil & Fuel Dealer said Low Vis Hy-Gard in JD 4100 Front Axle?

   / Dealer said Low Vis Hy-Gard in JD 4100 Front Axle? #1  

timbits588

New member
Joined
Mar 11, 2020
Messages
21
Location
WNY
Tractor
JD 4100, JD 318
Hi All,
Long time lurker for my 318, but recently picked up a 4100 and looking for some advice. Wanted to change all filters/fluids. Went to the dealer and picked up Low Viscosity Hy-Gard for the transmission. Asked for two gallon jugs of their 80W-90 as well because the manual states that GL-5 80W-90 is required for the front axle.

The fellow at the parts counter told me that the 5 gallon bucket of Hy-Gard I was getting could be used for everything so I could keep it simple.
I've been searching in an effort to verify that, but have had no luck. I've seen that on some of the new 1025's and such that what he said is the case.
My 4100 is a 1998 gear transmission. Probably over-thinking this, but wanted to start out on the right foot.

Thanks for any advice. Heck of a first post, I know. -tim
 
   / Dealer said Low Vis Hy-Gard in JD 4100 Front Axle? #2  
I am not a Deere guy, but if I had a gear drive Deere I would not need low vis HyGard for anything. Now I would consider regular HyGard for the front axle and definitely use it in the transmission / hydraulics.
 
   / Dealer said Low Vis Hy-Gard in JD 4100 Front Axle? #3  
My 4310 calls for low vis Hygard in the front axle.

I use the Premium Travelers oil on all my stuff which claims to be compatible. My NH backhoe uses the same oil in hydrualics, trans, and both axles.

According to the 4100 manual your tractor takes GL5 80W-90

Recommended Lubricants
Engine Oil:

John Deere PLUS-4®

John Deere PLUS-50®

John Deere TORQ-GARD SUPREME®

Engine Coolant COOL-GARD PRE-DILUTED SUMMER COOLANT

COOL-GARD CONCENTRATED SUMMER COOLANT

Transmission Oil John Deere Low Viscosity HY-GARD® (J20D)

Front Axle Oil John Deere GL-5 Lubricant®-SAE 80W-90
 
   / Dealer said Low Vis Hy-Gard in JD 4100 Front Axle? #4  
Hi All,
Long time lurker for my 318, but recently picked up a 4100 and looking for some advice. Wanted to change all filters/fluids. Went to the dealer and picked up Low Viscosity Hy-Gard for the transmission. Asked for two gallon jugs of their 80W-90 as well because the manual states that GL-5 80W-90 is required for the front axle.

The fellow at the parts counter told me that the 5 gallon bucket of Hy-Gard I was getting could be used for everything so I could keep it simple.
I've been searching in an effort to verify that, but have had no luck. I've seen that on some of the new 1025's and such that what he said is the case.
My 4100 is a 1998 gear transmission. Probably over-thinking this, but wanted to start out on the right foot.

Thanks for any advice. Heck of a first post, I know. -tim

That's a nice tractor, and from the era when they were made to last a lifetime. That's originally a Yanmar design front axle, and when it first came out it was a major change in front drive design. Now that design is common to most front wheel assist tractors. I've followed that design with interest since the late 1970s.
I don't know about you, but I like to look into what the lubricant is supposed to be doing and compare that to dealer/mfg. recommendations.

That's an excellent axle design. And nobody has higher quality than Yanmar. I've never heard of a problem with that front axle due to any type of lubrication used. Problems come from overloading the front end with too much stress from the loader, or using the tractor in axle-deep water and then not changing the lube for years. Not from the type of lube.

Like any axle with a cantilevered output shaft that is loaded in one direction, the eventual fate of all that type axle is that it will seep oil at the output seal where the output shaft axle connects to the wheel. The rest of it is pretty bulletproof. Yours will leak or seep there too when it gets a few thousand hours on it.....particularly if it has a loader. When that happens, the 80/90 wt. will seep less. Until it does, the Hygard will do a better job of lubricating the moving parts inside - particularly in cold weather.

From Yanmar I've seen recommendations for using both a trans/hydraulic oil like HyGard or a 75 to 90wt. SAE gear lube - both of which have approximently the same base viscosity as a 30 wt. engine oil - although they have different additives than an engine oil since they don't have to deal with combustion. Apparently Yanmar themselves will oscillate on which is preferred. The Lo-Vis HyGard has a slightly lower viscosity that either, and that is an advantage in cold climates. Think of lo-vis Hygard as being somewhat akin to a multi-viscosity engine oil.

The guy at the counter is right. Because your transmission case is also your hydraulic reservoir sump, both that gear transmission and the hydraulic system use the same fluid. Not just the same type, but they share the fluid. Hygard is a premium (and expensive) lubricant that will work in tranny, hydraulics, and the front axle too. And if you think about it, that sharing of fluid is also an excellent reason to change the hydraulic filter fairly often as well. Once a year for the filter, and every 600 hrs for the fluid is a reasonable recommendation for Hygard. Either the lo or regular viscosity. Regular is fine, but use the lo vis if you do a lot of cold weather work like snowblowing.
good luck,
rScotty
 
   / Dealer said Low Vis Hy-Gard in JD 4100 Front Axle? #5  
According to the owners manual, you need GL-5 GEAR LUBRICANT®-SAE 80W-90 in the front axle.
Here is a link to the manual.

Service Transmission
 
   / Dealer said Low Vis Hy-Gard in JD 4100 Front Axle?
  • Thread Starter
#6  
Wow, thank you all for the help! I have both the Owner's Manual and the dealer Technical Manual, so I know they recommend the GL-5 80W90. That was where my confusion came in because the parts counter told me otherwise. I really appreciate the insight from everyone and the accompanying explanations! What I was told makes much more sense now.
 
   / Dealer said Low Vis Hy-Gard in JD 4100 Front Axle? #7  
I would go by the manual. I have gotten wrong information from the parts counter before. After all, if things go wrong, they would be selling you more parts.
 
   / Dealer said Low Vis Hy-Gard in JD 4100 Front Axle?
  • Thread Starter
#8  
I would go by the manual. I have gotten wrong information from the parts counter before. After all, if things go wrong, they would be selling you more parts.

That is true, and was my original intention. I had never heard the Hy-Gard being mentioned with the front axle of a 4100, which was really what got me thinking. Especially after researching and finding that it is actually called for in several models' front axles.
 
   / Dealer said Low Vis Hy-Gard in JD 4100 Front Axle? #9  
All of the John Deere compacts that I have owned that were built by Yanmar used GL-5 GEAR LUBRICANT in the front axles. The JD built compacts all used Hy-Gard in the front axles. The Kioti uses GL-5 GEAR LUBRICANT.
 
   / Dealer said Low Vis Hy-Gard in JD 4100 Front Axle? #10  
I'd believe the manual. Never use a GL4 type gear oil (closer to what Hy Gard is) when it calls for a GL5. My Miata calls for GL5 in the differential and GL4 in the trans. I'd never put GL5 in the trans. Yet, I had a 1965 Plymouth Valiant that calls for either ATF or GL4 in the 3M. Could hardly be shifted with GL4. ATF worked great, as it does in Corvette MTs.

Anyway, I'd believe the manual over the counter guy. Gear oil (as pointed out, it's like 20 or 30w engine oil with fewer additives) is what I put in the front axle of the JD 4010.

Ralph
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2020 AMCO F42B-3626CS 13ft Pull-Behind Disc Offset Harrow Tiller (A49461)
2020 AMCO...
1974 Ih Farmall 1066 Tractor (A50514)
1974 Ih Farmall...
2015 Ram 1500 Crew Cab Pickup Truck (A49461)
2015 Ram 1500 Crew...
Unused 2025 CFG H15R Mini Excavator (A49461)
Unused 2025 CFG...
2005 Big Tex 10PI 16ft. T/A Pipe Top Utility Trailer (A49461)
2005 Big Tex 10PI...
2005 Chevrolet C4500 Altec Bucket Truck (A50323)
2005 Chevrolet...
 
Top