1455v vs. 1552

   / 1455v vs. 1552 #1  

Mailman17

Bronze Member
Joined
May 7, 2006
Messages
62
Location
Georgia
Tractor
2005 Mahindra 4110 TLB
I have found a 1455v that is still new and never purchased. I can by it for about $3000 less than a 1552. Both are 4wd and have same options. Dealer has had it since 10/04. It has 1 hour on meter. Is this a good buy or a great risk ?
 
   / 1455v vs. 1552 #2  
Tractor options that are often overlooked in comparisons by new buyers include the transmission type. A difference here can make up the 3K difference. Look them over carefully before making price comparisons.
I've been happy with my 1455v. Both are new, so there shouldn't be "great risk" with either. I haven't had time or the interest to study the "improvements" made on the 15xx series but I'm satisfied they are at least on par with the 14xx counterparts if not better.
 
   / 1455v vs. 1552
  • Thread Starter
#3  
It has the same 12x12 trans. I also was priced by a different dealer on an Agco ST52a for $2000 more than the 1455v. It is the same as the 1552 except orange . Owners of either model please reply . Also should I get the loader from the dealer or from an after market brand ?
 
   / 1455v vs. 1552 #4  
The 1455v used a MF 1040 loader and the 1552 I believe uses a new MF 1530 loader. Don't know what the operating pressures are on the 1552/1530 loader. The spec sheet on the 1040 indicates 1800 lift capacity to full height at the bucket edge and 3061 breakout force at bucket edge when used on the 1455v with pressures set at 1850 PSI. The spec sheet on the 1455v indicates hydraulic operating pressure at 2276 PSI, so the loader performance MIGHT be upped a little from what is stated. The same 1040 rated on a 451 as 1975 lift cap and 4645 breakout force with pressures set at 2500 PSI.
The 1530 spec sheet indicates 1617 lift capacity 19.5" forward of pivot pins and breakout force at bucket edge 2960.
I suspect that both loaders are about equal but haven't operated the 1530.
I favor buying the loader to match the tractor, but that's just an opinion. There are good and bad of both aftermarket and tractor name brands.
I've worked mine pretty hard and it's served me well. My dealer and Massey have been straight up with their service with the problems that have come up and I'll buy from them next time if I can. Although I haven't driven the 1552, I don't see enough difference to pay $3000 more for one. In a few years your tractor's value will be determined more by how it looks and has been serviced, hours use, etc. than the particular model number or year sold unless a particular model has a lot of problems.
The Agco is basically the same tractor with different paint and maybe a little sheet metal change. Don't know about where you are, but Massey dealers are generally more attuned to agricultural markets and tractors while CAT folks lean toward the industrial and construction markets. The dealer can make a big difference in your comfort zone if you ever have problems, and all brands have problems occasionally.
Good luck with your shopping.
 
   / 1455v vs. 1552 #5  
Both are good loaders. FYI, The 1040 loader has been replaced by the 1530 loader in this application.
 
   / 1455v vs. 1552 #6  
I waited and bought the 1552 because my Massey dealer said they were having trouble getting parts for the 1400 series. Have been delighted with the 1552 and if I get smarter will post a picture.
 
   / 1455v vs. 1552 #7  
If he is having problems getting parts for the 1400 series why would the 1500 series be any different...they are both made by Iseki?!?! /forums/images/graemlins/blush.gif

And if you say because the 1400 series is an older model then what happens when your 1500 series is an older model?!?!

Not what I would want to hear from a dealer....
 
   / 1455v vs. 1552 #8  
He is blowing smoke for some reason. I have had a 1400 for about 2 and half years and have never ordered anything that I couldn't have in overnight. I am sure that some chassis parts might take longer that aren't really something that is needed very much, but I have never had any problem.
 
   / 1455v vs. 1552 #9  
Jerry I agree he is blowing smoke...but why would a dealer try to sway a customer using this method?!?! I would think if anything that the dealer would want to get rid of the older unit...that statement alone would be reason enough for me not to buy from that dealer. JMHO.
 
   / 1455v vs. 1552 #10  
I agree. It doesn't make any since. I would look for another dealer or speak to the owner if that wasn't who he spoke to.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

FMC 757 Sprayer (A50121)
FMC 757 Sprayer...
2009 International 7400 Chassis Truck, VIN # 1HTWGAAR29J160609 (A51572)
2009 International...
JMR 72" Root Grapple (A50121)
JMR 72" Root...
2018 Toro Grounds Master 7200 72in Zero Turn Commercial Mower (A50322)
2018 Toro Grounds...
2012 Ram 4500 Chassis Vesralift 29ft Bucket Truck (A50323)
2012 Ram 4500...
2009 Skeeter SL190 19ft Boat with 21ft Boat Trailer (A51694)
2009 Skeeter SL190...
 
Top