Buying advice... Utility Tractor New vs Used

   / Buying advice... Utility Tractor New vs Used #1  

mf40diesel

Member
Joined
Nov 18, 2013
Messages
27
Location
western, ME
Tractor
Massey Ferguson 461, mfwd
Hello All... Need some advice.

I am a pretty sizeable tractor lover.. been in love with them my whole life. Have had two now... first a '52 Ford 8n... and now a 1971 Massey Ferguson 40 Industrial. The massey was a disaster when I bought it, still looks horrid- needs a painting really bad, however it runs perfect. Rebuilt the engine, brakes and countless other things. Some big things are still bad, and the loader is totally hammered to death. I want to upgrade again. I really want 4wd, as the Massey is clearly 2wd and therefore about worthless in the woods. ( I mostly use the tractor for gathering firewood (hauling tree length trees) then moving cut wood, Landscaping in the summer, road maintenance, I have a micro small business bushhogging some friends fields, and moving snow in the winter.

I am currently looking at a 1994 John Deere 5200, 4100 hours MFWD (turf tires so I need to swap them for some R1 or R4's) previously owned by a golf course. Allegedly they take really good care of their stuff. It has the 9X3 synchro tranny. I am having a great repoir with the guy selling it, and quite honestly would really like to shake the guys hand.

On the other hand... a really late model Massey Ferguson 2615. Power Shuttle tranny (I really like that).. I guess really thats the best part. That and the fact that its super new and would likely last years and years.

The other aspect... Although I am really not happy about alot that our government is doing, I do love the USA. The deere was made in the USA... the Massey (like the new deeres of the same size) made in India. While I have no problem with India.. I seem to really want the US made machine more..... but I really want that power shuttle!

The big problem: Can I really justify the new Massey simply cause I want it? Any advice would be great.

Probably the quality-control of the massey from india is better than the Deere from the States... probably the sad part.

Thanks in advance.
 
   / Buying advice... Utility Tractor New vs Used #2  
the 4100 hours on the deere would be a deal breaker for me. I recently bought a Kubota L3200 and really love the little beast. I'm not sure how you can justify the shuttle shift, but thats my first choice as well.
 
   / Buying advice... Utility Tractor New vs Used #3  
No contest. Get the Massey.

(Many US manufacturers source their tractors world wide.)
 
   / Buying advice... Utility Tractor New vs Used
  • Thread Starter
#4  
I know.... Pretty much all of them are. Built overseas. The ship I work on.. US co. Japanese made ship... Currently in a Korean shipyard.

The Massey wins... I kinda hoped it would. I really love my Massey, if it were 4wd drills, and in much much better overall condition I'd keep it forever.
 
   / Buying advice... Utility Tractor New vs Used
  • Thread Starter
#5  
How bout a deere 5045 vs massey 2615???? Both Indian made.. Pretty close specs.
 
   / Buying advice... Utility Tractor New vs Used #6  
Difference for me was that Buying used allowed me to get my wants while new would have only covered my needs. I found my current tractor with a cab (want), hst+ (want), auto throttle advance (want) with only 290 hrs for what a stripped down open station new tractor would have run me.

YMMV
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2019 GEHL RT105 SKID STEER (A51246)
2019 GEHL RT105...
2023 UNVERFERTH 432 LOT NUMBER 32 (A53084)
2023 UNVERFERTH...
COUNTER WEIGHT (A51247)
COUNTER WEIGHT...
2007 FELLA SM350 3 PT DISC MOWER (A53472)
2007 FELLA SM350 3...
40' CONTAINER (A51244)
40' CONTAINER (A51244)
2020 GP Equipment 24in Excavator Bucket (A51691)
2020 GP Equipment...
 
Top