Comparing YT2 and YT3

   / Comparing YT2 and YT3 #1  

rockyridgefarm

Elite Member
Joined
Mar 21, 2002
Messages
4,794
Location
NEOklahoma
Tractor
Yanmar YT347
The lovely Mrs Rocky and I finally made it by the Red Tractor Store yesterday! We checked over the YT235 and YT347. Then we test drove both. It was a blast!

We do have some limited experience on other machinery; the bulk of ours is on our Deere 4310 which we are looking to replace. It is fitted with Ag tires, and I can say the Industrials behaved quite differently.

It was pretty evident that the Deere fits right between the two Yanmars in size. The 2 series looked a bit smaller and the 3 a bit bigger than we are accustomed.

The initial reaction when we sat on them is that they are quite hot! Ok, who chose black seats? She let me try both first! It was 102 and there was no shade. But, it really wasn't too bad (or the seared flesh was deadened to the pain). It is ok, as I have a seat cover on my yellow one and will do the same with a new one. After buying one replacement seat, I like covers!

We drove the 347 first. I have to say that I want it to fit. The setup is SO nice. The Loader controls, included remotes, and full information instrument cluster really stand out. I see a grapple in my future. This is the machine to handle it. Not to mention, A host of other jobs like handling round bales, and pulling a nice size brush cutter.

The reverser selector was in easy reach and operated quite well. The accelerator pedal felt really nice. While, this is the area that is most foreign to our workflow; I now see that it is really an improvement over the two pedals. Even after 14 years, they still aren't the perfect solution when the brain tells you that pushing down more creates more power (it doesn't).

Then we tried the 235. Well! It fit like a glove (that's a good thing) and felt far more powerful than its smaller size suggested. It really seemed stronger than the 4310 - which is strange considering they have the same base engine but the newer is Tier IV. I tried stalling it in a gravel pile and couldn't. But later, realized that may be more do do with the R4's than anything else.

Initially, I have to say that both are fantastic. It is evident that the 235 is capable of handling a belly mower and is ideally suited to a large estate, mowing, drive maintenance, snow removal.

The 347 is a whole other animal. Too big for real yard mowing; it is much netter suited for heavier work, logging, grappling, loading, pasture mowing, and road making. The size is really well suited to those tasks - a smaller machine would be prone to self destruction. Worse still, is the potential for operator injury. Our place is very interesting terrain (get it - rocky ridge farm?). It is far too easy to get into a situation that pushes beyond the limits of safety.

One thing that was a truly pleasant surprise for her was the heat shields in front of the operator station. That small touch would make pasture mowing much more enjoyable.

By the way, we only briefly looked at the cab versions. Very, very nice! But, we are NOT considering that. We really like the open station. But, even with our heavy timber, the 235C looked like it could actually work. Still, it isn't for us. Mrs and I like to be out side when we are outside. And getting in and out of AC isn't a safe way to work in Oklahoma. Finally, one of us is legally blind and does far better in open (not that he gets it away from her much!)

I hope we can swing the YT347!

I like the mix of tech and grunt. The Yanmar axles and transmission are sure to compliment their legendary Diesel. I prefer the 4TNV over a turbo'd 3TNV.
 
Last edited:
   / Comparing YT2 and YT3
  • Thread Starter
#2  
Sorry that we didn't get pics!
 
   / Comparing YT2 and YT3 #3  
That is a really great write-up rockyridge! Thanks for sharing. I go back and forth between the YT235 and the YT347. Based on your description it sounds like maybe the YT235 would be better suited for my eight acres of property maintenance in Virginia.

Cheers, and let us know what you decide. And post pics next time!
 
   / Comparing YT2 and YT3
  • Thread Starter
#4  
Yup. If you are going to be using it on a real lawn, the 235 is it. Probably with turf tires.
 
   / Comparing YT2 and YT3
  • Thread Starter
#5  
So I got some seat time on the Deere last night. It hit me what I couldn't quite figure out during my test drive. Hydro whine. Neither Yanmar had it. Of course the 347 didn't. But the 235 sure seemed to lack it as well. Mind you, I wasn't specifically listening for that; it may be that I just didn't notice it.
 
   / Comparing YT2 and YT3 #6  
I'm thinkin' the 347 or 359 is for you Rocky Ridge......80 acres.... you need more size and power than the 4310. Tell Mrs Rocky Ridge that the internet recommends the 347/359.....:)
 
   / Comparing YT2 and YT3 #7  
We've had our YT347 open cab for about 2 months now. At first we thought about the YT237, but it seemed a bit small for our 74 acres. My son has the LX4100 and we didn't want to get anything smaller then that. So far we've mostly used it for grapple work and stump removal using the B90 backhoe. We are pretty happy with the YT347.
 
   / Comparing YT2 and YT3 #8  
It sure is nice to have a small tractor, maybe one smaller even than the YT237? But you need the bigger YT3xx first. As things get more manageable get a second tractor for chore work.
 
   / Comparing YT2 and YT3
  • Thread Starter
#9  
Yes, she and I were able to discuss this fully. She wants the 347 for the very reasons that you all mentioned. And a smaller one later Now, i wish that I still had my Yanmar 186d - 18Hp, 4wd, with powershift. It was sweet. But, something in that size, later.

Now, to see if we can swing a deal!
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

MI-T-M PRESSURE WASHER (A52472)
MI-T-M PRESSURE...
2000 Thomas Built Saf-T-Liner MVP-ER Transit Passenger Bus (A51692)
2000 Thomas Built...
Target Ecoline Walk-Behind Concrete Saw (A49461)
Target Ecoline...
2009 CATERPILLAR 420E BACKHOE (A51406)
2009 CATERPILLAR...
JOHN DEERE 850J LGP DOZER (A52472)
JOHN DEERE 850J...
1993 Ford F700 Stakebody Truck (A51692)
1993 Ford F700...
 
Top