Drywall surface - repair or replace?

[newbury]

Background -
Previous owner used shelf paper for drywall covering. Over the years I've "cleared" a couple of walls with time and moisture.

However SWMBO decided she could help and while I was on travel and proceeded to remove the shelf paper AND patches of the exterior layer of paint AND sometimes drywall paper AND sometimes some of the gypsum core. I've patched some places by removing the old drywall down to the studs and putting up new.

However some have suggested that I just "mud" over the bare patches with thin layers and sand it down.

What does the TBN crowd think is easiest? Mud or tear out? Will mud stay? We plan on just painting over it, not putting up wallpaper.

thanks

 

[Western]

You can mud a textured finish on, with the right colors blended it can turn out real nice. Tons of books and info on the net and I believe Home Depot and Lowes also sell various "kits" and products for it. Nice thing is, you can paint over it later if you want the texture but tired of the "tones". Texture may be cheaper and easier over a tear out too, may have to price it and take everything into consideration.

I helped a buddy do a 2 story stair case, only difference was it had only one layer of paint, so we sanded it lightly and went to trowl'n!

 

[MarkV]

You can mud over it in my experience. In areas that the gypsum was knocked out I would fill and then tape over, like a joint. Doing several thin layers will make for a better finish. Feathering out by using increasingly larger blades helps. If you are new to drywall finishing the biggest mistake people make is to put too much mud on per layer.

MarkV

 

[MossRoad]

How large of areas to fill are you talking? And is it in a large, lit area where people will be looking down the length of the wall?

Looking straight on at a wall it is harder to detect flaws VS looking down the length of a wall, like a hallway, when you enter someone's great room.

 

[newbury]

You can mud over it in my experience. In areas that the gypsum was knocked out I would fill and then tape over, like a joint. Doing several thin layers will make for a better finish. Feathering out by using increasingly larger blades helps. If you are new to drywall finishing the biggest mistake people make is to put too much mud on per layer.

MarkV

If I'm using store bought mud do I thin it w/ water at all? Usually when I'm doing joints I "caress" the last layer lightly with a wet sponge before letting it finally dry to sand.

 

[Western]

If you put a heavy texture on the wall, I dont think you would have to bother with imperfections

Look at some of the photos here, the one with the reddish tint and the light looks "neat". Sky is the limit if you do a heavy texture.

 

[cdaigle430]

Background -
Previous owner used shelf paper for drywall covering. Over the years I've "cleared" a couple of walls with time and moisture.

However SWMBO decided she could help and while I was on travel and proceeded to remove the shelf paper AND patches of the exterior layer of paint AND sometimes drywall paper AND sometimes some of the gypsum core. I've patched some places by removing the old drywall down to the studs and putting up new.

However some have suggested that I just "mud" over the bare patches with thin layers and sand it down.

What does the TBN crowd think is easiest? Mud or tear out? Will mud stay? We plan on just painting over it, not putting up wallpaper.

thanks

I had paneling-nailed and glued to wallpaper glued to sheetrock.When I removed the paneling sometimes the glue seeped through the wallpaper and pulled some of the sheetrock paper off. I removed the wallpaper and glue with lots and lots of hard work. For phase II of III I hired a drywaller to finish up the seems cause I am one of the worst mudders and sanders in the world. He did both walls for 350 bucks-the entire wall so that everything was smooth and seemless. Next week I put on a coat of primary but it looks soooo much better just with the sanded mud on.

I still have one section i need to get the paneling and wallpaper off and asked him for an estimate on the mudding and sanding for that section. What he suggested shocked me which was just to cover up the paneling and wallpaper layers with a layer of new sheetrock. Still thinking about it

 

[Western]

CJ, that sounds like a deal (adding new over old) you would loose what ?1-1/2" of room space, but save allot of work. IF that wont "bother" you later:laughing:

 

[/pine]

As MossRoad asked...how many boards are you talking about?...just one wall? two walls?

If it was no more than that I would skim them out...the beauty of sheetrock is that it is an imperfect product/art...it's all about the mud...

FWIW...I've never seen a professional finisher BOT add some water to "ready mix" joint compound...and something the real pros do on the final skim coat is add a drop or two of dish soap to the mix...it breaks the surface tension and makes a very slick finish...

 

[dex3361]

I usually use all purpose drywall mud in the 5 gallon buckets for patch work. If I am doing a whole house I use durabond 90 joint ccompound followed by their topping compound. You can certainly skim coat a wall, Just remember not to try to add to much at one time. Most pros will make 3 passes and their done. Me it takes 4 passes and a touch up or 2. If I am skim coating over paint I make sure the wall is clean and wash it down with TSP. I have had no failures with the mud falling out or peeling. Remember put little on and sand a little off.