French drain for the whole lot?

   / French drain for the whole lot? #1  

Village Idiot

New member
Joined
Aug 28, 2009
Messages
20
Location
Northern NH
Tractor
Kubota 4240; Deere 4020
A question for those with more (any) experience...

I have a gently sloping piece of land (~40 acres) that gets a lot of water drainage from farther up the hill. This is not really surface run off, but 3-4 feet down is glacial hardpan so anything above this is always damp/wet and I'm trying to think of ways to drain it. My first choice would be to dig trenches that start at the upper corners of the property and come together in the middle (like the shape of a "Y") and then dig a big hole at the base of the "Y" to make a small pond. I figure the trenches will be 3' deep, and I'll install a PVC pipe surrounded by crushed stone and fabric.

My question is: how important is it to dig a super accurate slope over the course of several hundred feet? and do you think it is easier from the bottom (drain side) up, or from the "top" down to the pond area? Also, any other tips??
 
   / French drain for the whole lot? #2  
A question for those with more (any) experience...

I have a gently sloping piece of land (~40 acres) that gets a lot of water drainage from farther up the hill. This is not really surface run off, but 3-4 feet down is glacial hardpan so anything above this is always damp/wet and I'm trying to think of ways to drain it. My first choice would be to dig trenches that start at the upper corners of the property and come together in the middle (like the shape of a "Y") and then dig a big hole at the base of the "Y" to make a small pond. I figure the trenches will be 3' deep, and I'll install a PVC pipe surrounded by crushed stone and fabric.

My question is: how important is it to dig a super accurate slope over the course of several hundred feet? and do you think it is easier from the bottom (drain side) up, or from the "top" down to the pond area? Also, any other tips??


A little more info may help. Such as.., how much room do you have above, or rather up the hill, from where the water seems to be perking out, to make the soil damp..??

If you have enough room "up the hill", to dig down about 3', elevation wise, to reach that hardpan, then that is where you want your trench. Actually picking up the water before it gets to the point where it seeps to the top, or out. Where the water seeps out is probably close to where the hardpan/rock, or whatever..., crops out. Water follows the path of least resistance.

You don't say where you live, so I'm assuming the water is either coming off the rock, or fire clay, like we have in our area. But in our area, above the fire clay is coal... Even a small seam of "Blossom" coal will carry a lot of water.

If you have a hoe to dig some test holes would be a big help. Dig down and see what is actually there. Not any larger than you need to, just to see what is there, where you want to trench.

If it is rock, it may be laying flat like Mother Nature made it. Unless it is an outside crop that has tilted down on the outside edge, you may get some fall... Or fire clay as mentioned above. On hillsides, softer layers of shaley sedimentary rock underneath, may have been washed away, and allowing it to drop.

A few test holes near where you want the trench, and a transit or level will tell you how much fall you have to work with. Just make sure you reach the hardpan to find that level. Stay on that hardpan with your trench to catch all the water. If it happens to be fireclay ( pretty gray clay, like modeling clay) do NOT go through it..!! Stay on top, right down to it. The dirt will peel right off of it, leaving a nice clean, but slippery surface if wet.. If you break through it, you may loose you water, and will filter through some..., more than likely shale, and crop out at a lower level somewhere in the field.

You may need to modify your "Y", or if the rock is flat, just dig a straighter "Y" across, and catch the water. And collecting in the middle is your best bet. Who knows what you will find, and not be able to get the fall you need, if going full length to drain. I wouldn't go less than a 2% grade on the fall if possible.

We always started at the top, and worked down. You never know what you will find. A sudden drop in the hardpan, or a saddleback rising up. You will need to cut through whatever, to allow the water to get out. Otherwise, you've created a low spot to collect water. Yes, it will flow out, when it gets deep enough to flow over top of that high point. But if not cut to allow the water out, you've created an underground ponding of water, that will cause you more problems than you already had.., volume wise of water, in that particular area. Let alone the "head", or pressure created by the depth of the water, before reaching the point of flowing over the high spot.. This will continue to seep out, like it did before, or worse.

At least a foot of gravel over the pipe, IF this is just surface/ground water soaking down to the hardpan. We used a lot of 4", 360コ perforated, lined, black plastic pipe. This is not the plastic pipe that comes in rolls. This comes in 20' straight pieces. The crush strength on this is lots greater, than the roll pipe. You may do a price comparison vs. PVC. Much easier to work with, and what we used had the snap together ends. We secured with 3 screws, to keep it from popping apart, in deep trenches.

Over top of the gravel, however much you feel comfortable with in the trench..., (You just have to make sure you've picked up the water source.) we laid strips of either geotech cloth, or have used roof felt cut in strips the width of the ditch, even doubled over, to keep the dirt from filtering in.

With all we've put in, and a few we have had to dig back up, because someone didn't know how to read a stick, or didn't have one..., and caused the above "ponding" issue.:eek: I've never seen any that had dirt that had fitered in, because we didn't completely surround the stone and pipe with geotech cloth. You'll just have to use your own judgement on this... Whatever you are comfortable with. We had surplus geotech, that contractors turned back in from large road jobs. We would cut it to width with a chainsaw, off the large roll. It kinda' half melts, and makes a mess under the chain guard, but lot's easier than cutting strips with a knife...

At the "T" in the "Y", we used a small section of perferated to get started, then into solid pipe.. This we did wrap with geotech, and covered with dirt. More or less forcing the water into the solid, so as not to leach out going down the hill. Most of our drains ran across fill material, and didn't want it saturating, what we'd just put in.

At the outlet, we slipped various types of pipe over it, to protect it from being crushed. We did have a nice stock of what our supervisor called "whistle pipe". 5" galvanized, corregated steel pipe in 10' sections. Schedule 40 6" works well too...

I always like to underdig under the last 2-3' of the outlet, and place like 6" # 2 limestone under it for something to splash on...


And just for good measure... Drive a post beside the outlet marking the drain... attach a highly visible sign, reflector, or something on it...

If you get a good stream of water coming out of your pipe, where you want to dig your pond, you can always buy a roll of the 4" to divert it away from the work area, or..., just dig a temporary ditch to divert it..., or dig the majority of your pond first, and hope it's deep enough... What ever works best for you... What seems to be a slight trickle of water, can produce a lot of water, in just 24 hrs. A stream the size of a lead pencil will produce pprox. 500 gallons in a 24 hr. period...


Oops.... Looks like I got a little carried away..!! :eek:
 
   / French drain for the whole lot? #3  
I agree with what you posted and if he has a major university close by or check with Dept of Ag. and see if there is any geologial maps or data for his land that might give a hint as to what lays beneath. Just a thought.
 
   / French drain for the whole lot? #4  
Very true..!! I also happened to think of water well drilling records. But that would all depend on if his water well is at the top of the hill, above this, or below. Or maybe a neighbor on "up the hill"..

In Ohio, you can check these drilling logs, if you can find the address.

Well drillers here are required to log on the drilling record, what they drill through.
 
   / French drain for the whole lot? #5  
Where are you located, are wetlands protected where you live as they are here, and what type of soil & subsoil?

What you describe is _very_ common 'here', we have 200+ feet of clay soils here, with viens of different types, and sidehills bleed out & need tiling to farm them. Dad tiled the bottoms many years ago, but all the sidehills are not the problems.

See your FSA office to see about permits. They get _real_ serious here if you try to drain without a permit!

It seems pointless to drain to a bottom & then make that area too wet - typically you run the tile to a drainage ditch.

As mentioned, you run the tile a little higher than te wet area - catch the water before it gets tot he wet pooled area.

Good to run tile every 100 feet or less in the wet areas. Called 'pattern tiling'.

But if you have different soils then I donno.

--->Paul
 
   / French drain for the whole lot? #6  
I know that in some areas, for example Arizona, in order to get the land to "drain," they have to rip the soil very deep. They use cats with long ripper blades and rip open the "hard pan."

This suggestion may be absolutely not doable....however you might look into hiring someone who would have a three or four foot ripper. Have them come in and rip down into the cleche and break it up. This is not anything similar to plowing. You would not be rolling the soil up. Of course if you cannot break up the cleche/hard pan, or rather break through the stuff, then you are back to your original idea of using a french drain type of system.
 
   / French drain for the whole lot? #7  
You could also ask the local ag people for some info, our usda people are very helpful. I had some quesitons about water run off and I was given a bunch of options, and pamplets that helped me decide on what and how to control the water. Always over plan any water, if you dont and you take all that water to one place it could over power and make the situation worse.
also remember if you do bring all your water together in one place how will this affect your neighbors, will it discharge more water to them?

When working on the drainage on our property i talked to my neighbor and we worked at making sure we could divert as much away from his house and into his pond as we could.
It allowed him to run his sump pump less.

I used the 4'' black perf pipe surrounded by crushed rock (2b). We had a wicked storm come through and a rock was carried down stream and clogged the pipe. Now the pipe is like a pretzle and 2b rock is all over the yard. I will be putting in a second drain pipe and then re covering it. I didnt anticipate the amount of water and now i am re doing it.
 
   / French drain for the whole lot?
  • Thread Starter
#8  
About a year later, I finally got around to digging the trench.

I live in New Hampshire, and the ground in the forest consists of a few inches of dirt (humus is the technical term iirc) and pretty quickly gets down to clay. The backhoe can dig through all of this, but it is a little more work to get the clay out. I think most of the water is just filtering down the hill through the topsoil, along the clay. I dug about 600' of trench about 18-24" deep so I'm well into the clay layer. I started at the top and was digging down hill, but the trench filled up with water pretty fast and I didn't like digging in a pond, so I turned around and dug the second half from the bottom up and just joined up in the middle.

My thought was to see how much water this drained from the hill, and how dry it made the rest of the property. If it works well, I can fill it in with rock/pipe next summer.

I went out yesterday in the rain to see how it was doing. **** (rhymes with spam) there is a lot of water flowing through that trench! I would estimate the flow was way more than 5 gpm (probably more like 50 gpm). You could hear the water rushing from about 50' away. All the brooks around us were running pretty high (higher than summertime, not as high as spring thaw). After seeing the water yesterday I'm concerned a 4" pipe won't be big enough to handle the volume. I'm concerned two 4" pipes would be full, and I know you don't want the pipes completely full, so I'm now thinking about an 8" pipe. This may be too big for the depth I dug (it probably dips to 16" at some points) but I sure don't want to put in too small a pipe.

I plan to leave it till springtime when I can rig some way to make an accurate measure of peak flow, and then base the pipe size on that.

Thanks for all the advice so far. I am re-impressed at the scale of the projects that are doable with this tractor, and the quality of help/advice that comes from this message board.
 
   / French drain for the whole lot? #9  
if you can go with the bigger pipe, and maby back fill with rip-rap stone (the larger hand sized chunks of stone when filling it in. I had one of the smaller pipes get clogged on me and it uprooted the whole section and washed all the 2b gravel away i had down. now ill use the bigger stone this spring. a landscaper i worked with once said that he always overestimates the power of water when figuring out drainage, and makes the system a bit larger.
 
   / French drain for the whole lot? #10  
About a year later, I finally got around to digging the trench.

I live in New Hampshire, and the ground in the forest consists of a few inches of dirt (humus is the technical term iirc) and pretty quickly gets down to clay.

I live in New Hampshire too, and my area of interest is similar, except for the loam/humus. I have an area near my barn that is sandy clay, and a good portion of it was always soupy. Water leaches out of the bank that is on the edge of the property, which I think runs along a layer of solid blue clay from a 6 acre beaver pond that is a few hundred feet away (uphill). I trenched it last year to relieve the water near where it leaches out, then I dug a french drain similar to what you are thinking about this summer, although not nearly as big. I dug the trench about 2' deep, and 2' wide. I filled it with 3/4" washed stone (that's the expensive part of the job) and used 4" perforated black flex drain pipe. I graded the area to form a culvert that runs above the french drain, then I loamed and seeded the area. Seems to be working so far.

4993035738_11f006351a_b_d.jpg


4993036692_71be19f96a_b_d.jpg


Note how majestic my L4200 looks in the background :). Unfortunately, I don't have a finished picture for some reason.

8" pipe seems like a good idea to me. I put a few inches of stone into the trench, then laid the pipe, then covered the pipe with about a foot of stone, for 18-24" total. You could probably put an 8" pipe in a similar trench, but I wanted to be able to drive over top of the drain w/o worry, so I made sure to put extra stone down.

Since you seem to be trying to handle rain runoff, you are going to need to design in an overflow - no matter what you do, it is going to get over overwhelmed sometimes. If you do like I did, and grade the ground above the drain into a culvert, that might be adequate for overflow conditions.

JayC
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2025 New/Unused LandHonor 13,000lb Electric Winch (A51573)
2025 New/Unused...
2019 JOHN DEERE 8245R LOT NUMBER 187 (A53084)
2019 JOHN DEERE...
2020 RoGator RG1300 Air Max Precision R2 Spreader (A53342)
2020 RoGator...
1995 Chevrolet K2500 Pickup Truck, VIN # 1GCGK29F2SE237154 (A51572)
1995 Chevrolet...
2019 JOHN DEERE 5090M LOT NUMBER 92 (A53084)
2019 JOHN DEERE...
2016 Kenworth T270 Truck, VIN # 2NKHHM6X1GM110171 (A51572)
2016 Kenworth T270...
 
Top