The closer you get the material to the lift pins, you will be able to lift more. By curling up, you are doing just that.
A pressure of 2500 psi on a 2 in cyl will produce about 7864. The lever principle comes into play here, and the distance of the load to the lift points will dictate the actual lift force.
For each 100 psi increase, the force will increase about 315 lbs.
If you should raise the pressure 2500 to 3000, the lifting force will increase about 1589 lbs. I used these figures as a reference only.
This is computed with a straight on push. If the cyl is angled to the lifting device, the force will be less.