rac717 - FWIW I did a deep dive on OIC (the insurer) and they look like a very solid organization. Good financials, good reputation, been around ~62 years, even the employees there like it on Glassdoor. OTOH they are small - like 7 agent managers and ~25 subcontracted adjusters (circa 2016 when Ohio reviewed them), so I can see how the 'subs' may not always represent the insurance company well. Gaffes like this really shouldn't happen but between the VP, KTAC & your dealer it's pretty clear that all the serious forces are aligned in a very positive direction. Not sure about forum etiquette, but your dealership deserves a mention.