Bob,
You bring up an excellent point... relief valves. It would seem to me that the relief valves for the lift arm cylinders would be set to prevent you from lifting something that would damage the tractor -- not relying on the seat of the pants "PT pucker factor."
As a simple example, I think if your PT was facing uphill on a steep slope, you could lift more than if you're sitting on level ground before the PT pucker came into play...
I think I've now read through this entire form at least a couple times, and I've not read of anyone talking about the relief valves kicking in when they tried to lift something -- only the PT pucker coming into play. This makes me wonder if:
(1) the bypass valves are actually set correctly to prevent damaging the tractor -- especially if adding more weight to the back of the tractor (such as you and only a very few others have mentioned) still doesn't cause them to bypass... On both my Kubota loader and the Henry loader that I had on an old Allis-Chalmers before it, I could frequently cause the valves to bypass when I tried to pick up too much... Note that this is not good for the system if you do it repeatedly, because it can send hydraulic pulses, causing the system to "shudder"...
OR
(2) maybe the PT pucker factor isn't REALLY the design limitations of this hydraulic system, and perhaps the 800 lb rating (which seems somewhat accurate on where the pucker factor kicks in -- based on some anecdotal tests posted) is actually a bit higher than the pucker factor. I also wonder if that rating considers the geometry of the PT tractor design itself, where most of the weight is far behind the lift arms as
ballast. Surely the standard rating system used would take into consideration the design of the tractor...
BOTTOM LINE: It would seem to me that those valves SHOULD be set to bypass somewhere around 800 lbs, if that is truly the rating for this system...
Yet, how may people have reported their lift valves bypassing, rather than the tractor attempting to pick up the load, and instead picking up the rear of the tractor????
Once I get my PT 425 home, I think some experimentation is in order....
BTW, this has nothing to do with whether or not the lift arms themselves are rated for more than 800 lbs -- you might bend them, for example -- only what are the real design limits for the hydraulic lift system...