Navistar engines and Allison's to avoid?

   / Navistar engines and Allison's to avoid? #1  

QRTRHRS

Elite Member
Joined
Nov 25, 2005
Messages
2,888
Location
Liberty, Kentucky
Tractor
None at this time.
I have been surfing around the net looking for a medium duty truck. My preference would be a four door FL70 with an 8.3 backed up by a nine or ten speed. Plenty of M2's out there but they are too new. I am finding more IH crews in my price range, mostly with the DT 466 backed by an auto.


I won't go with anything but an inline six. Any IH diesels to avoid?

Same question about the Allison auto's. I know nothing about them. i would think a five speed would be better than a four though?
 
   / Navistar engines and Allison's to avoid? #2  
The DT466 is a great motor..... there are millions of them on the road. IMO, their weak point is the fuel mileage....but relatively inexpensive to repair when needed.

Have you given any consideration to the Cat 3126? I had one in my FL60...... sold it with a half million miles on it. Its probably still going strong.
 
   / Navistar engines and Allison's to avoid?
  • Thread Starter
#3  
The DT466 is a great motor..... there are millions of them on the road. IMO, their weak point is the fuel mileage....but relatively inexpensive to repair when needed.

Have you given any consideration to the Cat 3126? I had one in my FL60...... sold it with a half million miles on it. Its probably still going strong.
I just happen to have more experiance with Cummins engines but, sure, I would consider a Cat.

The truck will be for farm use so while mileage is always a concern, it won't be a major consideration. What kind of mpg did you get with that Cat?

Is the 3126 the C7? I put a few miles on a 2005 or 2006 C7 rated for 275hp. That one got around 7mpg but was plagued with injector issues.
 
   / Navistar engines and Allison's to avoid? #4  
Cats are not known for their good fuel mileage. My C13 gets 10.7 bobtail and 6.6 - 7.7 @ 43k.
 
   / Navistar engines and Allison's to avoid? #5  
I have been surfing around the net looking for a medium duty truck. My preference would be a four door FL70 with an 8.3 backed up by a nine or ten speed. Plenty of M2's out there but they are too new. I am finding more IH crews in my price range, mostly with the DT 466 backed by an auto.


I won't go with anything but an inline six. Any IH diesels to avoid?

Same question about the Allison auto's. I know nothing about them. i would think a five speed would be better than a four though?

None of the DT466's are engines to avoid, however, some year ranges are better than others. First, I would suggest a power rating of 230HP or more.
My favorite years are the '93-'95. They have a P-pump similar to the 5.9L Cummins pump which a 3rd grader can modify for more power. The injectors are a whopping $35 each, so it's cheap to hot rod or maintain. Next favorite for me is '90-'92. I have this model. It doesn't have a P-pump. It has a Robby Bosch punp that is easy to modify for more power, but not to the degree of the P-pump. Pre '90 DT's have the rotary style pump which is better left alone.

The "NGD" (New generation Diesel) are electronic and started ~'95. They are more difficult to modify being electronic. I think that's the year they started with the HEUI injectors, which are also about $300/each. So figure on much greater expense for replacing injectors.

Moving forward, the Dt466 has basically had the same "improvements" that other diesels have undergone (electronic, more complicated, emmissions, etc.) but the basic engine has remained dead-nuts reliable and bulletproof.

As far as the allisons, they have become much better & more reliable over time. If you're looking at DT466/allisons, the earlier models up through about 1990 came with AT545's. Simple 4 speed autos. I would say to avoid them. Dime a dozen to replace, but not enough gears and no lockup gears-maybe 4th gear. Next generation allison was the MT series which had more gears and more lock-up, but no O/D, so almost all of them run 1 to 1 in top gear. So if you buy a 5.38 reared truck, you might be able to hit 55 MPH. You have to know the rear ratio before you buy or road test to determine top speed. The MT series was a big improvement over the AT series. You'll typically see an MT-653 in a '90's DT466 powered IH truck.
After ~'99, they came out with the electronic MD "World" series transmissions. Ford bought hundreds of thousands of these off GM/Detroit/Allison for their "F-Series" trucks for decades. The 1000/2000/2200/2400/3000 are the most popular names for them. These transmissions are the also called MD3060's in a lot of IH trucks. These are the ones you want. They have double OD's in them allowing for greater fuel economy, lower RPM's, higher road speed and most importantly, more lock-up gears. Typically, they'll lock in 2-6. 1st gear will be available for off-road useage. The gear selector will be a touchpad. These transmissions rock. They can also be analyzed/updated through an elecronic "OBD" type diagnostics port and laptop.

If I were buying another IH with a DT series and an Ally, I'd look for one with an "MD" series electronic auto with the features I mentioned. Much nicer to drive/own. The MT's are a step backwards.

I don't know what years you're looking at or what you want to spend. My DT466 is super easy to work on yourself and a real puller when loaded. I had an F-700 with an AT454, and F-800 with a MT653 and currently have a GMC3500 with a Allison 1000 series. I can tell you the 1000 series is more transmission than either the MT653 or the AT454 that i previously owned & serviced.

My current IH has a Spicer 6+1 manual. I only wish it had an Allison automatic.

http://www.allisontransmission.com/product/
 
   / Navistar engines and Allison's to avoid? #6  
I just realized in my post above I called the AT545 an AT454. It's really an AT545. :)

2 other IH diesels I would not consider are the DT360 and the DT408. You probably won't encounter any of them and they have been out of production for over 10 years. There's nothing wrong with either in terms of "hardness" or "toughness", but they're typically rated only in the 170-210HP range and lack enough displacement for MD applications.
 
   / Navistar engines and Allison's to avoid?
  • Thread Starter
#7  
Thanks for chiming in Builder. I gotta' nominate you for the resident Navistar expert after reading all of that.

From what specs I can remember from my searching, you have it covered. Now I need to run with it.

I am looking to come in under around 15k. Air brakes because I think they are better and less expensive to maintain than vacuum over hydraulic. Locking rear. Nine or ten speed over an auto. Empty weight less than 15,000 lbs.

I am going to try to go with a flatbed dump that will accomodate a gooseneck. With a class 6, weight should not be an issue even with a crew.

For a single cab, I would prefer a Freightliner over an IH for leg room but really want a crew. Seems like the crews in my range are all IH's. The legroom is my only issue. Other than that, an IH would be fine.
 
   / Navistar engines and Allison's to avoid? #8  
Just curious on why you are against the allison auto. They weigh less than a gear trans and the World trans is pretty much bullet proof. On the 95-96 Dt 530 we have had problems with the oil pans cracking.
Bill
 
   / Navistar engines and Allison's to avoid?
  • Thread Starter
#9  
Just curious on why you are against the allison auto. They weigh less than a gear trans and the World trans is pretty much bullet proof. On the 95-96 Dt 530 we have had problems with the oil pans cracking.
Bill
Not really against Allison's. Just old school I guess because I prefer to do my own gear selection. Realistically though, if I find everything else in a truck that I want but with an auto then I will go with it.

Heck, I just picked up a used F150 with an auto because I had to park my dually. I have to admit, I do enjoy my morning coffee on my way to work without having to shift but I sure miss that throttle response, lol!

Most things mechanical get tweaked and/or improved over time. Sometimes those tweaks don't quite work as planned. That's why I asked.
 
   / Navistar engines and Allison's to avoid? #10  
Not really against Allison's. Just old school I guess because I prefer to do my own gear selection. Realistically though, if I find everything else in a truck that I want but with an auto then I will go with it.

Heck, I just picked up a used F150 with an auto because I had to park my dually. I have to admit, I do enjoy my morning coffee on my way to work without having to shift but I sure miss that throttle response, lol!

Most things mechanical get tweaked and/or improved over time. Sometimes those tweaks don't quite work as planned. That's why I asked.

(Hopefully) I will never own another manual transmission in a MD/HD in my life. Allison has proven tests that show their transmissions make a truck faster than even the most professional driver can shift a manual transmission. They actually sponsored a "showdown" between trucks to prove it. With more lock up gears, fuel mileage & power transmission is almost the same now as a manual in medium duty trucks, maybe better now that they have double O/D's.

When I'm done work, the last thing I feel like doing is working my truck on the way home, especially while towing. In snow, they don't break traction like a manual.

Allison is really a work of art in transmissions. With their retarders that can rival a jake brake in braking horsepower, downshift capability, push-button gear selector boxes and lock up gears, it's no wonder they lead the world in heavy truck autoshift transmissions and no wonder companies like Ford & IH buy automatic transmissions from them instead of building their own.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

RoGator RG1100C (A50397)
RoGator RG1100C...
1998 Three Horse Slant Trailer with Tack Room (A48836)
1998 Three Horse...
2016 Ford F-150 4x4 Ext. Cab Pickup Truck (A48081)
2016 Ford F-150...
2018 John Deere 8370R MFWD Tractor (A50657)
2018 John Deere...
New/Unused 14ft Bi-Parting Iron Gate (Elk Design) (A48837)
New/Unused 14ft...
PALLET OF ARMSTRONG TILE FLOORING (A50460)
PALLET OF...
 
Top