Panik
Gold Member
- Joined
- Mar 29, 2013
- Messages
- 491
- Tractor
- Kubota bx2360
So I've been a bit remiss about posting this up. About a 1000 miles or so ago we were able to replace our '06 Jeep Commander with a '14 GMC Sierra. Ended up getting a 2wd Z71 crew cab short bed with the 3.42 axle.

Gotta say it was actually kinda sad leaving the jeep at the dealer, kind like the whole King of the Hill episode when Hank's truck dies. It took me a couple minutes to realize why. The jeep was the car that we used to bring all three of our children home from the hospital. It was also the first car I purchased for my wife.
On the other hand the truck fits our needs so much better than the jeep did. If for no other reason than the crew cab gives me enough room to stretch my legs and not have the steering wheel in my chest, while giving the kids enough room so that they can't kick the seat backs.
It also is averaging a heck of a lot better gas mileage. At the end the jeep was down around 13 mpg. Two days ago I pulled our 20 equipment trailer (~2000 lbs) down to Atlanta to move my wife out of her grad school apartment and we averaged about 15 with towing. The last time I tried towing with the jeep mileage dropped to around 8mpg.
About the only two issues I might complain about are the grade braking while in tow/haul mode and the amount of bouncing the truck did while trailering when we hit rough patches. There were two times coming off a fairly steep off ramp when the grade braking kicked in hard enough to jump the rpm's up to around 3800. Surprised us both times when it happened because there was absolutely no lead up to it. From reading, my understanding is that some of that may diminish with time as the adaptive transmission "learns" we'll see.
As for the bouncing/porpoising I would suspect that is a result of going with the Z71 suspension. I probably don't do enough towing for it to be a big issue. I'll have to see how it goes with a heavier load. The jeep would do it as well, but it was both harsher and less drawn out at the same time. I can always look at doing some mods down the road if it truly is problematic.
Speaking of mods the first was installing the brake controller some where it was both accessible and not apt to be sideswiped by my knee. I hate the idea of drilling into the dash. I figure if velcro works for NASA it should work for this application:

Second mod was de-badging the bleeping tailgate of the truck. No offense to those folks who like their emblems, but 4x8 GMC logo, SLE badging and the Sierra badge were just too much for that piece of real estate. I still have to remove the dealer emblem, and may well take the door badges off as well. I always hate how stuff like that pics up wax build up.

Also it was kinda funny about a week before we bought the truck I found this pic online. Sent to my wife in a text while she was in school saying that whenever we got a truck she was going to have to let me treat her to a tailgate dinner on top of one of Lavender Mtn. Week later I wind up with almost the exact same truck as in the picture without realizing it.


Gotta say it was actually kinda sad leaving the jeep at the dealer, kind like the whole King of the Hill episode when Hank's truck dies. It took me a couple minutes to realize why. The jeep was the car that we used to bring all three of our children home from the hospital. It was also the first car I purchased for my wife.
On the other hand the truck fits our needs so much better than the jeep did. If for no other reason than the crew cab gives me enough room to stretch my legs and not have the steering wheel in my chest, while giving the kids enough room so that they can't kick the seat backs.
It also is averaging a heck of a lot better gas mileage. At the end the jeep was down around 13 mpg. Two days ago I pulled our 20 equipment trailer (~2000 lbs) down to Atlanta to move my wife out of her grad school apartment and we averaged about 15 with towing. The last time I tried towing with the jeep mileage dropped to around 8mpg.
About the only two issues I might complain about are the grade braking while in tow/haul mode and the amount of bouncing the truck did while trailering when we hit rough patches. There were two times coming off a fairly steep off ramp when the grade braking kicked in hard enough to jump the rpm's up to around 3800. Surprised us both times when it happened because there was absolutely no lead up to it. From reading, my understanding is that some of that may diminish with time as the adaptive transmission "learns" we'll see.
As for the bouncing/porpoising I would suspect that is a result of going with the Z71 suspension. I probably don't do enough towing for it to be a big issue. I'll have to see how it goes with a heavier load. The jeep would do it as well, but it was both harsher and less drawn out at the same time. I can always look at doing some mods down the road if it truly is problematic.
Speaking of mods the first was installing the brake controller some where it was both accessible and not apt to be sideswiped by my knee. I hate the idea of drilling into the dash. I figure if velcro works for NASA it should work for this application:

Second mod was de-badging the bleeping tailgate of the truck. No offense to those folks who like their emblems, but 4x8 GMC logo, SLE badging and the Sierra badge were just too much for that piece of real estate. I still have to remove the dealer emblem, and may well take the door badges off as well. I always hate how stuff like that pics up wax build up.

Also it was kinda funny about a week before we bought the truck I found this pic online. Sent to my wife in a text while she was in school saying that whenever we got a truck she was going to have to let me treat her to a tailgate dinner on top of one of Lavender Mtn. Week later I wind up with almost the exact same truck as in the picture without realizing it.
