Pad or no Pad

   / Pad or no Pad #1  

Silver_Knight

Silver Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2006
Messages
114
Location
Marble Falls, TX
I have two quotes for a slab for my new 50x86 barn. The first quote of 25,500 is for a pad that will be 5 foot larger than the slab plus the slab. The second quote is the slab only for 20K. These quotes are from the same guy. My question is what is the advantage of having the pad built? The back side of the slab will be 30" high by going without a pad.
 
   / Pad or no Pad #2  
Pad material should cost less than concrete.

The pad also provides a compacted area that hopefully has natural drainage.

Egon
 
   / Pad or no Pad #3  
The big difference is going to be drainage. If there will be water running alongside the slab there is a chance that it will erode and eventually run under the slab. Building up the pad around it will help avoid that situation. Depending on your drainage you might not have a problem without one though.

One person mentioned a nice thing about not having a pad was putting a door on the part of the barn that is 30" high and using that as a natural loading dock.

I built my own pad site up this weekend for my 30x40 barn. It ended up costing $800 and about 20 hours of work. ($500 of fill dirt, $100 rental of a jumping jack and $200 labor for the kid to run the jumping jack) I had received a quote to do it for $1,200. In retrospect I should have just hired it done, but at least I got some experience using the tractor and felt like I accomplished something. I know I packed it in good and solid with 4 separate layers with packing each layer down good.

I only built my pad about 1 foot extra and then it slopes down at about a 20 degree angle for another 8 feet or so at the tallest spots. This takes care of any erosion problems but it doesn't leave a very nice work area around the building if you need to work on it.

That's my 2 cents worth.

Nathan
 
   / Pad or no Pad
  • Thread Starter
#5  
I also thought it would be cheaper to build up with a pad but from the price difference I guess I will go with a slab on grade. The 30 high slab in the rear will not effect anything since there are no doors on that side. Drainage also does not appear to be an issue.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2010 Ford Edge SE SUV (A51694)
2010 Ford Edge SE...
2016 FREIGHTLINER 2500 SPRINTER VAN (A52141)
2016 FREIGHTLINER...
Husky Tandem Tank Spreader (A50774)
Husky Tandem Tank...
Ford F-450 Utility Truck (A52748)
Ford F-450 Utility...
2010 Ford Edge SE SUV (A51694)
2010 Ford Edge SE...
Toyota 6FGU25 Forklift  5,000 lb Capacity (A52748)
Toyota 6FGU25...
 
Top