I put 30 6 inch posts for my dog yard a few years back, I used a 12 inch so that I could jam rocks on the sides of the post down 36 inches..
I finally bought a "post hole digging/tamper bar". It's a serious 6 foot pry bar (weighs 20-30 lbs?) that I use for about everything else besides post holes, but it is great for tamping the dirt along the side of the post at every level as you fill the hole back in. Once your done the post is wicked solid compared to just stomping the surface level dirt around the post.