I wonder if your shuttle control is similar to the Branson 8050 and 7845 shuttle controller, or even the same.
My 8050 works better if I just use the shuttle lever,
if I use the foot pedal it is very touchy and shakes and shudders,
it is very difficult to move just an inch or two.
I actually have to go into first gear and A range to have any type of smooth control with the foot pedal.