Upgrade Existing Tractor or Trade for New?

rebelback · Jun 8, 2021

I currently have a 2010 Case IH Farmall 45 HST with ROPS that I'm fairly happy with. I'd like more tractor (who wouldn't), but it gets the job done. My only problem with it is that it has no quick attach for the FEL or a 3rd function remote . My dilemma is this, should I add a quick attach and 3rd function for roughly $3,000 or should I just trade new for a 65hp (or something in that range) with power shuttle shift that comes with both of these options? I'm wanting to add a grapple this year and hopefully a TB-1 or Lane Shark by next spring. It seems like the market is so crazy right now on used that I could possibly sale my current tractor and purchase a new Mahindra 65hp with these options plus a grapple for not much more than what it would take to upgrade my current tractor. I'm not sold on a Mahindra either, but I really don't want to deal with DEF on another brand. I could also probably get a tax break on the new model since it would be classified as new farm equipment that I could depreciate.

mcfarmall · Jun 8, 2021

The problem is that you might have to wait months for your new tractor. If I were you, I'd wait out the craziness until the market(s) stabilize and then make your purchase. As far as the DPF business, most of them on the mid range tractors work flawlessly. Some folks have struggles with DEF systems freezing up or whatnot. I postponed a construction project indefinitely because I refuse to pay $12 for a 2x4x8.

TractorTYMe · Jun 8, 2021

If you're happy with your 2010, I would just say add the extra needed to suit your demands. Otherwise you will add long wait times for new equipment, DPF and tier 4 emissions to your potential headache.