Which of these two?

[blackburb]

So looking to replace my ancient Ariens rider as the motor is just about dead. I have a flat, 3/4 acre yard. These two are probably more than I need, but they've caught my eye and curious what the experts think. I need to stay under the $1400 stimulus

1) 2003 JD LX277 AWS. 17hp Kawa, K62 trans, 48", 617 hours, $1200. I like the Kawa, and the K62, but a bit concerned about the all wheel steering from a maintenance/repair standpoint. 48" is definitely big for my yard (it's broken up into 5 small areas by bushes, garage, storage building, etc.

2) 2008 Simplicity Broadmoor 20H. 20hp Briggs Vanguard, K57 trans, 44", 418 hours, $1400. Looks to be in somewhat better cosmetic condition and has 200 fewer hours.

Both are located around two hours from me but in the same general direction so I could look at both in one trip.

Thanks!

 

[stevem5215]

I'd get the Simplicity just because I think it sounds like a better and newer machine.

 

[bigtiller]

Both of them are priced a little high but I would drive past the Simplicity to buy the Deere.
Don't be shy about the AWS. Like Martha says, "It's a good thing."

 

[Williy]

blackburb where u be?​

I will sell you my cub cadet! 6 hours cutting grass
time. Put a electric fuel pump on it starts right up
no grinding on starter


willy

 

[Carl_NH]

Condition and care is likely the deciding factor. Both are good machines, but like SteveM said, 200 fewer hours and 5 years newer and if what you indicated was a better kept machine - I would vote Simplicity.

I agree for the age, both are about $2-300 overpriced IMO but depends on your local market too.