Buying Advice Your Tractor selection Process

/ Your Tractor selection Process #1  

69runner

New member
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
10
Location
Pacific NW
Tractor
Cub Cadet
Hi Everyone:

I was wondering about how long it took you to select and purchase your tractor. And, was this your first tractor or did you previously own or have some experience with tractors?

The reason I'm wondering is, I seem to be stuck in the old "paralysis by analysis" syndrome. I keep moving from tractor to tractor seeing both the strengths and weaknesses of each. I have really enjoyed spending the time reading about the different tractors, sizes, and implements since this is my first tractor. However, being into to the process about three months now I am not much closer on a decision.

I know everyone has different requirements and needs but just trying to see if most of you had similar experiences.

Thanks Much,
69runner
 
/ Your Tractor selection Process #2  
Dealer who was closest was a factor -- it helped to see him at the county fair, etc. Also, HP and weight for price w/ included FEL.

Overall, it took only a few days for me to decide when I was serious about it, but I had been mulling it over in the back of my mind for several months.

Owned "Satan" (an old 1970's Case 580 backhoe) first.

Marcus
 
/ Your Tractor selection Process #3  
I researched for around two years, while saving my money. I asked many different tractor owners questions throughout this time period. In the end, I narrowed my choices to two makes and models. I drove both models and made my decision, based on my present and future needs. One of the deciding issues also involved the profession demeanor and honesty regarding the dealership. It has been a year since I purchased my tractor and I can honestly state that I am happy with my choice. Best wishes.
 
/ Your Tractor selection Process #4  
Hi Everyone:

I was wondering about how long it took you to select and purchase your tractor. And, was this your first tractor or did you previously own or have some experience with tractors?

The reason I'm wondering is, I seem to be stuck in the old "paralysis by analysis" syndrome. I keep moving from tractor to tractor seeing both the strengths and weaknesses of each. I have really enjoyed spending the time reading about the different tractors, sizes, and implements since this is my first tractor. However, being into to the process about three months now I am not much closer on a decision.

I know everyone has different requirements and needs but just trying to see if most of you had similar experiences.

Thanks Much,
69runner


My process became more of selecting a dealer than a tractor manufacture. Within my area, John Deere, Kubota, and Kioti had dealer presents. From researching and asking questions here, I learned that all three brands were considered bullet-proof with Kioti being the newest member to the bullet proof family.

I talked (interviewed is more like it) with the dealers, detailed my needs and listened to what they advised. Some said they would call me back (and didn't) and some were just arrogant. Nothing than hasn稚 happen to most of us shopping for a tractor.

The dealer I selected turned out to never pressure me, always found time to talk with me, actually talked me down in what I thought I needed, and gave me real usage information. Turned out he has a lot of property close to where I live and had the experience I was about to learn.

He is a small dealer, what most would call a mom and pop operation, didn稚 advertise but relied on referrals. His business is built on customer satisfaction. Everything he told me (2 years now since I bought the tractor) turned out true and the one thing he always told me was a smaller tractor will do what a bigger tractor will do, just differently. I sized my tractor to the common tasks and have no regrets doing so.

The experience taught me not to shop for price but to fill the needs first, then find a dealer and select the model and features you want. A tractor is typically a long or life purchase so why worry about a few thousand dollars in options and features? I treated myself to a more featured model and after doing competitive pricing, the dealer I chose was still better priced than the rest.

I did good choosing my dealer and after 2 years and the customer service I致e had since, well, I致e done good. Right now, my dealer lent me his excavator for a project I have, yep, lent!

Shop for a dealer and don稚 hold back. Failure is lying on your death bed wishing you would have
 
/ Your Tractor selection Process #5  
Dealer location and reputation is top priority for me. Want dealer within 100 miles with full service and parts departments. Bought two new tractors. My first was a 2005 Kubota B7510 HST with the LA302 FEL. Second was a 2008 Mahindra 5525 with ML250 FEL.
 
/ Your Tractor selection Process #6  
I bought my first tractor blind, and after that experience ( a bad one), found TBN. That was where the two year clock started and I went from "Do I want Green or Japanese Orange" to "Joining the Pack" mainly by reading comments from all the different forums. I finally just said enough and set out to drive each of the brands I was interested in and set my mind to buy whatever I was going to order by week's end. It had gotten to the point I either had to rent/hire to get stuff done, or go get another tractor.

Bottom line I guess is that if you need the tractor bad enough, then go get one. If you can do without it, then perhaps continuing to waffle on your choice is okay. It don't cost as much to review your options as it does to buy.:thumbsup:
 
/ Your Tractor selection Process #7  
I bought a 1947 JD B and fixed it up about 1990 then started looking at other newer tractors. Ended up buying a used JD 2240 and fixed that up. As it was getting 'long on the tooth', wanted to get something newer and keep the 2240 as a backup. Actually was looking the whole time. I would go to the Kabota, Case, and New Holland dealerships every couple years, download pictures/stuff online, and basically druil over everything from time to time. I think that being near a dealership is not that important unless you are farming or in a business where you can't live with downtime. Being 'comfortable' with the dealer and the person that MAY have to do some warrantee work is very important. I have a 2001.5 Dodge Cummins diesel pickup, and that along with all of my tractors.... have ever been close to a dealership after I bought them. A dealership to me is just insurance, backup for if I can't handle something. You can get parts from them or online.... your call.
 
/ Your Tractor selection Process #8  
lets see how long did it take for me to buy a tractor not long.we had come out of a rough wet muddy winter.an sticking the big 2wd drive tractor a few times.a buddy wanted me to go look at disc cutters with him.so i went with him an we ended up looking at tractors.i found the tractor i wanted pretty quick a MX5100 HST 4x4 w/LA844 quicktatch loader.so we got the price on just the tractor then added the loader.an we talked about it on the way home.an he goes you wont buy that tractor an i says yeah im calling in the morning to buy it.an thats what i did.but i wasnt looking to buy that day but i did.
 
/ Your Tractor selection Process #9  
First Tractor - Cub 154 LoBoy gear drive - When we built here 22 years ago, it was obvious the 30-some inch riding mower was up for replacement. Goal was to find something cheap with a big deck. A dealer had the LoBoy with a 60" belly mower and a front "dozer" blade that filled the requirements and then some. At that time our 100 yard drive was gravel and the blade looked like a good idea. It had rear tire chains with it so it worked for snow removal. Downside was the work required to switch between blade and mower because they both needed the same rockshaft to raise and lower.

Second tractor - Ford 1210 HST - After the LoBoy, I wanted a tractor that had a 3PH for implements. 4WD would also be nice. The same dealer I bought the LoBoy from happened to have the Ford at a price that I couldn't resist. It was on the second floor of an old building they are in, and they nearly forgot about it because it wasn't outside with the other equipment. It was funny to ride the freight elevator down with the salesman and the little tractor (running). Bought a Caroni 5' RFM and have beat the snot out of it after getting the next tractor. The Caroni deck has a lot of welds on it but it still cuts nicely. Almost sold the Ford when I got the next tractor, but it was too handy. This is the tractor that sold me on HST.

Third tractor - Kubota B7500 HST - Wanted something with a few more horses, and Wifey for some reason thought it'd be nice to have a loader. Shopped for used compact 4WD's and found a couple Kubotas that were OK but not exactly right. One had a loader but looked beat up and another was much nicer but it had a belly mower. The salesman gave me a great deal on a new B7500 / HST / FEL / Landpride RFM. Had that tractor till about a month ago.

Current Tractor - Kubota L3200 HST / FEL / Landpride 6' RFM - It was time for a larger more comfortable tractor with still a few more horses. Although the B7500 was good to me, there were other players this time. Bobcat, Kioti and Mahindra were all in the running. Prices were very close for three of them but the Bobcat dealer was just way too proud of his tractor. As I mentioned in another thread, the Kubota felt better to me. One real nice feature with the Kubota is being able to remove or reinstall the loader in a minute without getting off the tractor. My loader is never on for mowing, and it gets a fair amount of use. I mowed on Thursday evening and found myself a little disappointed that it was finished so soon. I would have been happy spending another hour or so on the tractor.
 
/ Your Tractor selection Process
  • Thread Starter
#10  
Thanks everyone. I do appreciate the input. I'll keep learning and seraching and looking for the best dealer. That too, I'm beginning to believe is probably the most important factor. That seams to be a very consistant theme from most folks. I'm still thinking the Mahindra Max28 or 3016 are great tractors and will be evertything and most likely more that I need.

Agian,
Thanks much!
69runner
 
/ Your Tractor selection Process #11  
Purchase based on dealer and NOT tractor color. In my case the best dealer experience happened to sell blue equipment!
 
/ Your Tractor selection Process #12  
Thanks everyone. I do appreciate the input. I'll keep learning and seraching and looking for the best dealer. That too, I'm beginning to believe is probably the most important factor. That seams to be a very consistant theme from most folks. I'm still thinking the Mahindra Max28 or 3016 are great tractors and will be evertything and most likely more that I need.

Agian,
Thanks much!
69runner

I am certainly one of the few on this forum who don't really care about the dealer selection process. I don't think they are nearly as important as everyone says. However, that is probably because I bought used with no warranty and also do my own work/maintenance. A main factor is whether you use your tractor for a living or not, I don't, so if it breaks and I need to order parts online and wait a few days, it's no big deal. This has yet to happen though. If your going with a new purchase I think the dealer is important, but not as important as what you want. Of course you need a dealer who will fix your tractor and honor the warrenty, but if you find yourself at the dealer every other week, then you probably want to go with another tractor. :D

My selection process was pretty simple for my first tractor (and current). Prior to my Kubota L4610 I used my fathers Case 275 and some old tractor that I don't even remember what it was. I knew I wanted hydro and I started looking around for used Kubota's and John Deeres. Mostly because I didn't know much about other manufacturers and was ready to purchase. I found a good deal on my tractor with low hours and went for it.

My current process is much different though, now I'm looking to buy a tractor in the next 2 yrs or so as an upgrade to my current tractor. I bought this tractor full well knowing that it would not be my last, but more of a stepping stone. If I can afford it, I would like my next one to be around for many many years, and I'd like to get exactly what I want.
I started listing all the implements I wanted to use on the tractor, as well as what they're weight and power requirement would be. I then thought of all the options I would like to have, and narrowed it down from there. I'm still narrowing. :laughing:
I currently have a running list on my notes app on my iphone and everytime I think of something else, I add it to my "tractor preferences" list. This includes any other attachments I may want in the future. No tractor will do it all, but I'm trying to narrow it down to the one that I would most prefer that would do 95% of what I would like to do.

I think it's important to decide what implements you want to use as well as what size, and what quality (as in light, medium, or heavy duty) and choose your tractor based on the best "fit" to those implements.

I bought my tractor without thinking much about what implements I would use on it, aside from the front end loader (FEL), this was a mistake, because I should have bought bigger, however it does most of what I need/want it for.

I'll probably catch **** for this, but honestly I don't see why many hobby tractor users think it's so vitally important to put the dealer first, unless like I said, if your going to buy brand spanking new. If your not mechanically inclined, or just prefer new, this is a good way to go. :thumbsup: (for the record, I would prefer to go new, but my price range would have only bought me a bx model kubota)
For my next purchase, I'm considering many more models and it most likely will not be a Kubota.

If this is your first tractor, I'd encourage you to go used with low hours. There is a good chance you will want to trade up (or even down depending on your uses) at some point in the next few years, and you will lose a lot less money if you buy/sell a used vs. a brand new tractor (of course, there are always exceptions.)

Sorry for the long winded reply, and WELCOME to the forum! :thumbsup:
 
/ Your Tractor selection Process #13  
Piston makea alot of good points imo, choosing the implements and tractor to match is important. It should be obvious that the more seat time you have the easier it is to decide which tractor is the best fit for you. For someone who is new to tractors in general the selection process can be intimidating and often these people buy too small and have to upgrade at a later date. I think the best way to approach the buying process is to provide the information about the property and what your expectation about improvements are in detail. Most of the forum members can then steer you into the proper size tractor with the features needed to accomplish your goals. I have found that most of the brands will have a model that will fit the varous needs well and then you can shop for the best dealer and color you like.
 
/ Your Tractor selection Process #14  
My main decision was HP, used, utility vs lighter weight compact utility and preferably 2WD because that was all I needed and it kept the price down. I made that decisision based on what I was going to use it for and what I wanted to spend to get something in that range. Looked at a whole bunch of used tractors of all different colors and age range.

Ended up buying a JD, not because of the color but because it was a 53 HP, 11 years with 128 hours on it and priced right. It was in good enough shape that I did not feel bad buying a new loader for it and still have less in it than I could sell it for. I have been very happy and glad I did not get too wrapped up into specs and comparing tractors. I am a causual user that has enough ground that I need a tractor so I did not worry too much about creature comforts and such since I only use it about 30 hours a year I could get by with anything. After all the 1955 MF 35 that blew up got me by for 16 years
 
/ Your Tractor selection Process #15  
I spent about 2 years looking for the right tractor. First choosing the size...which was hard for me to do since I could easily get too small OR too big since I don't have a big piece of property. Then it was finding the right brand with the right level of value. I didn't want to sacrifice quality and I'm a sucker for features. I ended up ordering my Kioti DK50SE...a great combination of quality and features at a price that allowed me to even get a backhoe, which I never thought I'd be able to afford when I was looking at Deere and Kubota.
 
/ Your Tractor selection Process #16  
Decided on price, then HP/size.

Went to the Mahindra, Massey, JD, Kubota dealers. Wrote a check for a L3800DT. Took two weeks and is my 4th tractor purchase. Very pleased!

Oh and I came in 4K under my budget. :D
 
/ Your Tractor selection Process #17  
For my first tractor what sold me was price and quality, and the added benefit was parts were relatively easy to obtain. I bought my Yanmar 169D after many months of watching craigslist for deals. It was a great little tractor, parts were easy to get via my local Deere and Kubota dealers, Napa auto parts, and Hoye Tractor. This last summer I decided what I really needed was something bigger, originally planning on a larger tractor with a loader I decided to sell the Yanmar and many of the implements I had for it. I sold the implements very quickly, however I didn't sell the Yanmar until Mid January. Durring the time I had the Yanmar for sale I was watching Craigslist for used skid steer loaders (would better suit my needs) and located a John Deere 317 skid steer up in Washington at a New Holland dealer. The price was right and once I sold the Yanmar we made arrangements and went up to take a look at the 317. Since I have had great experiences with my Local Deere dealer (and several others in the area) and the 317 was in very good condition I brought it home with me. The New Holland Dealer i bought it from was awsome, the week I went up to get it we had several inches of snow and ice on the ground and they had no electricity but still opened for me to come see the 317 and were very professional. I also have had great experiences in Deere's 300 series compact track loaders which also helped me in checking for any problems when I tested out the 317. So far I am very happy with my 317, it is a great machine, I have great local dealers, and I have done a fairly small amount of work to get the 317 up to my standards.
 
/ Your Tractor selection Process #18  
1st tractor- I wanted to upgrade from an Ingersoll 448 that I inheirited from my father. I wanted a CUT, but I knew they were more then I could afford then. I researched JD 400 series garden tractors-to set one up with a 60'MMM, blade, weights, and tire chains was going to be around 10K. This was in 2000. I had decided to purchase one in the spring, but this was when the Kubota BX tractors were first inrroduced. I looked at them and decided one of those would be the answer. I bought the tracto rand MMM for the 10K that I had budgeted, saved money and bought the FEL 6 months later. That tractor gave me 9 years of reliable service.

2nd tractor. B2620. I bought a ZTR in 2008, so I did not need the MMM on the BX anymore. I also bought 10 acres of property in 2009, and knew that I wanted a larger tractor to use on that property. I had begun a relationship at a Kubota dealer where I had some service work done on the BX and bought parts. I knew the size tractor I wanted, knew I wanted another Kubota, and liked the salesman. Walked in one day and bought the tractor within 15 minutes.

Will
 
/ Your Tractor selection Process #19  
1st tractor- I wanted to upgrade from an Ingersoll 448 that I inheirited from my father. I wanted a CUT, but I knew they were more then I could afford then. I researched JD 400 series garden tractors-to set one up with a 60'MMM, blade, weights, and tire chains was going to be around 10K. This was in 2000. I had decided to purchase one in the spring, but this was when the Kubota BX tractors were first inrroduced. I looked at them and decided one of those would be the answer. I bought the tracto rand MMM for the 10K that I had budgeted, saved money and bought the FEL 6 months later. That tractor gave me 9 years of reliable service.

2nd tractor. B2620. I bought a ZTR in 2008, so I did not need the MMM on the BX anymore. I also bought 10 acres of property in 2009, and knew that I wanted a larger tractor to use on that property. I had begun a relationship at a Kubota dealer where I had some service work done on the BX and bought parts. I knew the size tractor I wanted, knew I wanted another Kubota, and liked the salesman. Walked in one day and bought the tractor within 15 minutes.

Will
 

Marketplace Items

2015 International TranStar 8600 T/A Day Cab Truck Tractor (A61568)
2015 International...
2020 CHEVROLET SILVERADO CREW CAB TRUCK (A59823)
2020 CHEVROLET...
John Deere TX Gator (A60462)
John Deere TX...
2014 CATERPILLAR CB34B XW DOUBLE DRUM ROLLER (A62129)
2014 CATERPILLAR...
2006 Honda Ridgeline AWD Crew Cab Pickup Truck (A61568)
2006 Honda...
2019 Krause 8005-30 Excelerator - High Speed Vertical Tillage - 30 FT Working Width (A63118)
2019 Krause...
 
Top