Follow Up.
So I wound up purchasing an Igland 4501 from Reed Supply Co. in Vermont. $3000 shipped. Came with PTO shaft, 3 chokers, 3 slides and 165ft of cable on the drum. Availability at the time was a large factor, as they had them ready to ship. I really liked the Fransgard V-4000 winch but it was no longer available from the supplier that I liked. Other distributors were selling the Fransgard for much more money, around $4000 shipped. This was too far above budget for what I was looking for. I also already have an Igland Sundown GR40 grapple which I have been very please with, so going Igland again was comfortable.
The winch came on a pallet upon delivery, only assembly required was the butt plate, and the 2 cords for the clutch and brake. The PTO shaft was the perfect setup for my tractor, no cutting required in this case.
I was worried before I took delivery that this Igland 4501 would be a bit too large for my Kioti DK45se hst, but now that its mounted, and I have used it, I very happy with the decision. Even though the butt plate can hinge to get over obstacles, the 3pt hitch still lifts it plenty high off the ground, and when it is down, the pto is about parallel with the ground, which is good for operation. The butt plate is about 60" wide, and the winch is about 75" tall. It sits inside my rear tires and below my ROPs
The quality is quite good. Stout and fully enclosed, but easily opened up. Very simple and well organized. But 2 things I think could be improved. When the winch is not hooked up to the tractor, the kick stand that it leans on is not mounted in a very sturdy place. It's very strange as the rest of the winch is built so well. Nothing a few minutes welding in a gusset or two wouldn't fix, so why didn't they at the factory? Something I'll probably fix when I weld in a square receiver into the butt plate so I can tow things around. The way the Butt Plate comes off this should be very easy. Second is the manual. The exploded view diagrams were fine, but the operation/user manual is ****. Poorly written and vague. This machine may be simple, but I still feel it deserve a good instruction and care manual.
I'm very happy with its operation. With the butt plate properly dug in, and the engine at 1200 rpm, the winch pulled smoothly and powerfully. The tractor, in this case, is most certainly the limiting factor here, as I'm sure it could pull itself right over. But with proper operation, this is not an issue. I'd rather be in this boat, then have a small winch, as I will also be using it on my larger and heavier john deere 2510.
Overall I think the Igland 4501 is a simple and stout, easy to operate, no bells and whistles winch that will last a lifetime if properly cared for, which I'm not quite sure how to, as the manual is ****.
At this point, I'm very happy with the purchase.