I think the iPod is still the best MP3 player out there. The real advantage of the iPod is iTunes- the software that allows you to organize and purchase music, it also allows you to rip your current CDs to a digital format. For a novice you really can't beat the ease of use of both the device and the software. There may be better software and better devices, but it's very hard to beat the two together. As for it being closed, you can now purchase most of your music in a format that will play on other MP3 players without the Apple DRM- so it can be used without iTunes or an iPod. I do think it may cost a bit more to get the music without DRM. In my opinion, there are only two you should be considering- the Nano or the Touch. The shuffle doesn't have a screen and is difficult to navigate etc. If your goal is a music/podcast only device (although it can still play video), the Nano is the easy choice- it's small, has a video camera, is easy to use and less expensive. If you want to do more and use the device with the applications that are available- than the Touch is the way to go. The Nano is an MP3 playter, the Touch is a handheld computer that plays MP3s. I have a Nano I use around the homestead doing chores, on the tractor etc and use a Touch for work and travel- I use it as an organizer, to watch the occasional video, and a bunch of the apps from the iTunes store but don't use it as an MP3 player.