Wind turbine? Does it make sense?

   / Wind turbine? Does it make sense? #1  

dejswa

Bronze Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2009
Messages
54
Once a year, seems like I look at renewable energy sources and then I am disappointed because the up front cost never justifies the long term savings if one just looks at it from an economic point of view.

However, this year, with the new 'stimulus', I mean 'spending' bill, it appears that there are economic incentives that might finally tip the scales in favor of acting on the purchase of some sort of system.

The tax details are still not clear to me, but it seems that there is now an unlimited 30% tax credit for rural qualifying renewable energy investment (maybe urban also, but I will explain in a moment). In addition, one would get to deduct the cost of the equipment over time - what period of time I do not know.

This ad has some discussion of the current tax law:

Qualified Small Wind: Skystream 3.7 eligible for US tax credits

So, let's look at an example - suppose you spend $16,000 on a 4KW system. Your tax credit would be $4,800 - lowering the immediate cost of the system to $11,200. Now, in addition, you can deduct the entire cost of the system as it relates to your business (your farm, etc.).

Let's say you are in the 25% tax level and you deduct it over 5 years (possibly earlier by accellerated depreciation). Then that is $3200 deduction per year, saving you $800 real dollars per year x 5 years.

Thus, over 5 years, you will initially pay $11,200, then get back another $4,000.

Now, let's say that your turbine really generates only 30% of the max power on the average. At $0.12hat is $1,261 in electricity saved or refunded per year, for a total of $6,307 over 5 years.

Thus you now have been refunded $10,307 of your remaining $11, 200 over 5 years!

And I am only looking at 5 years. In another year, you will have paid off the entire thing in terms of cumulative savings. Of course I am not looking at the time value of your money up front. Of course, you might have had that money in the stock market and then you would have lost half of it and still not have a wind turbine.

They are saying that the life of the larger turbines is 20 yrs and even then you still have the infrastructure (tower, wiring, inverters) in place.

Now, if that makes sense, take it one step further. A 4KW turbine costs about $4 per watt to install to the point of being ready to use. Not much better than solar. But if you look at larger units, you can approach $2 per watt if you bump up to 20KW turbines. Then you have to start looking at the whole thing as an investment.

That's a lot of money, but you recoup it after exactly 3 years at $2/watt plus now you have the turbine for electricity and future profit.

I recently viewed a 4KW system on a 60 ft monopole and I was impressed at how quiet and unobtrusive it was. It didn't seem as tall as I was expecting and with a 20 mph wind there was more noise from the wind than the turbine. I think a 20KW system would go on a 80 to 100 ft pole.
 
   / Wind turbine? Does it make sense? #2  
I haven't checked into the new tax credits available now, but when I did this exercise last year it really didn't make any sense for me. Based on my usage (home, not farm), my electricity cost, and the cost of the turbine, it would take me 20 to 50+ years to get a payback. This didn't include the cost of money either. I could find a lot of other things to sink $16-$18k into.

-Dave
 
   / Wind turbine? Does it make sense?
  • Thread Starter
#3  
Yes, I am wondering if I am doing calculations correctly.

Am assuming:

$4/watt up front, turn key cost.
30% efficiency on the turbine (that is, an average of 30% of max output)
30% uncapped federal tax credit
25% federal income tax bracket and that you can depreciate it totally over 5 yrs.
$0.12 per KWhr electricity cost and $0.12 per KWhr payment for uploading energy to the grid.

Possible problems would be anything that negates the above premises.
 
   / Wind turbine? Does it make sense? #4  
Are you even in an area that has enough wind to utilize a turbine? Does wind blow in your area for enough hours in the day and strong enough to make power?

Do you have space to put the turbine up high enough to catch the wind? Will the tower require cables to hold it steady and do you have the space for those cables? Other wise you might need a different type of tower meaning more expense.

I take it that the .12 KWH payment to upload to the grid is net metering and your utility actually pays the producer retail rates for power. My power company will do net metering but they don't pay me what power costs me. They would pay a few cents less than retail.

Later,
Dan
 
   / Wind turbine? Does it make sense? #5  
What Dan said on wind source, and I might add, did you factor in any maintenance?

What about factoring in energy stores? Like batteries?

Lastly, local regulations?

I am under of all things a visual easement on a property.

The funny part is we can see "new" 500Khv towers on parcels, they obviously don't fall under the same restrictions. So check your local regs.....

Good luck.

Can you keep us posted on your progress? I am all about options.
 
   / Wind turbine? Does it make sense? #6  
You need a LOT of wind for a reasonable payback period(Greater than 15KT for sustained periods daily?). Enough wind that you complain about that dam wind on a daily basis is probably what you need. How to Site a Wind Turbine | eHow.com

As mentioned, tower and possible guys could be an issue. The wind noise from a tower and guys, as well as the blade noise of the rotor itself could also be a long term headache. With enough wind to be operating properly, the rotor will make some noise.
 
   / Wind turbine? Does it make sense?
  • Thread Starter
#7  
Yes, these are all good points here.

I believe net metering would work. I think that it is just about the physical properties of the meter. That is, I believe all 'older' meters will run in either direction, but I might be wrong - any comments on this?

As far as getting paid for excess energy. Not sure on this one. There is a potential problem here. One fellow told me that they were legally required to pay him, but refused and it took him a year in court to make it work. Major hassle factor there.

Regarding guy wires. I am on enough land that if it fell, it would stay well within the bounds of my property. Besides, the monopole structure are like what you see on the high power line towers. They are really sturdy and designed not to need the extra wires. Although they are about 4x more expensive than guy wired towers. A 60 ft tower needs about 10 yd of concrete - 8x8x8 foundation.

What an excellent point about 'no ugliness restrictions on high v. power lines'. It would be hard to counter the argument that a windmill is any worse than an ugly string of HV towers twice as tall with wires and insulators hanging all over!

Maintenance might be a factor - need to learn about - most turbines come with a 5 yr warranty - at least that's a start.

Re. batteries, if you can do net metering, you can do without batteries. If you want to be totally grid-free, battery systems appear to me to be a high cost and require management. Last time I looked into it, was around $5 per watt to set up a battery bank with charge regulation and inverters to go totally off-grid. That doubles the cost of solar and triples the cost of intermediate size wind power.
 
   / Wind turbine? Does it make sense? #8  
As mentioned, tower and possible guys could be an issue. The wind noise from a tower and guys, as well as the blade noise of the rotor itself could also be a long term headache. With enough wind to be operating properly, the rotor will make some noise.

this is the most common objection i hear from "people"

These are usually people that have never stood under a small scale turbine.

Takeing it from someone that has actually stood under a small scale turbine on a 20mph day for some time, its no more noticeable than the highway out front and certainly less annoying than aircraft over head or the trains that roll by on the tracks.
 
   / Wind turbine? Does it make sense? #9  
You might also check your local town or city for the taxation.
My town has gone 'public' with the word that if someone should add a ,say 30,000 solar system , their valuation will increase proportionally.
so say that small mobile here is valued at 15,000 and gets a solar remake. its now worth 45,ooo for tax purposes.
It doesn't make sense to me to penalize but thats how they view it.
 
   / Wind turbine? Does it make sense? #10  
The numbers sound good, but are based on returns that just might not be there.

A very good friend of mine owns a crane business. Before that, he was in the crane repair business and had the contract for two companies that owned the wind farms on the Altamont Pass in California. It's a very big wind farm. They went bankrupt because they couldn't afford to keep the windmills working. Rumor has it that newer turbines take less maintenance, and since he no longer has anything to do with those wind farms, I don't know for sure if it's true or not. I was there last year and was shocked to see how many of them had fallen over and had lost their blades. It's a mess.

From what I understand, you only generate electricity at certain wind speeds. It's very rare to find a place with consistent wind at the right speed. Then storing the electricity becomes an even bigger issue. For a home that is off the grid, it might have some use since you always want to be charging your batteries, but I think solar cells are better for this with less maintenance.

Windmills are very good for the companies making and selling them. They are crap for actually generating electricity over the long term and on a daily basis. If the government got out of subsidizing them, they would either disappear, or hopefully improve the technology. As it is, there is no real reason t make them better when they can sell them like they are and make a nice profit.

I also wouldn't rely on anything the government is saying today about future tax credits. They are changing the rules almost daily and just because they say they will do something today, has no bearing on what they say and do tomorrow. Relying on a tax credit next year and the year after seems like wishful thinking when they are working on ways to eliminate tax credits, increase taxes and spend more money. I think you'd have more luck putting your money into the market with a company making a profit off of selling the so called green energy with massive government assistance. As long as tax dollars are propping up those companies, they will turn a profit and their value should hold steady.

Good luck,
Eddie
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2009 Bruton T/A Enclosed Livestock Trailer (A55973)
2009 Bruton T/A...
2022 FREIGHTLINER CASCADIA SLEEPER (A56129)
2022 FREIGHTLINER...
Preliminary Listing / Full Catalog Coming Soon! (A53317)
Preliminary...
JOHN DEERE 5403 TRACTOR (A58375)
JOHN DEERE 5403...
SDLL30 skid steer with bucket (A56857)
SDLL30 skid steer...
2020 FREIGHTLINER CASCADIA 126 SLEEPER TRUCK (A59575)
2020 FREIGHTLINER...
 
Top