"Best" alternative to PT-4xx

KMA · Mar 22, 2010

This is just for fun and primarily out of curiosity, but what do you guys think would be the best overall, non-PT alternative to a PT4xx machine for your "average" homeowner? I know answers will be very subjective, but that's okay... just explain briefly your reasoning. (e.g. easier to operate/repair, better quality, price, etc)

Looking forward to some interesting suggestions. :thumbsup:

Thanks!

KentT · Mar 22, 2010

An Avant - same concept as a PT, with commercial-grade strength and a Kubota diesel and "real wheel motors"... too bad Gehl stopped importing them completely.

Avant Home

Gehl Company - Compact Equipment for Construction and Agriculture

I'd looooooooooove to have one -- but not enough to pay for it! :thumbsup:

MossRoad · Mar 22, 2010

The Kubota BX series is small, strong and versatile. Great machines. Great dealer support. Great factory parts availability. Strong puller. Diesel engine will last for eternity. Will load dirt in a pickup truck.

Will scuff lawns in tight turns in 4wd.
Lacks power down on 3PT hitch, so post holing is harder.
Lacks quick attach, so you have to buy one and convert all your 3pt implements.
Won't fit in the back of a pickup truck, so you have to buy a trailer.
Sits up higher so you may have ROPS hitting garage door.
No FOPS.
Costs more.
Lifts less.

Consider tasks to accomplish before choosing machine. Both are desirable machines.

BobRip · Mar 22, 2010

Dying and going to heaven.

Wait a PT1430. Diesel, 1200# lift capacity, quick attach, more torque, not very expensive, could be adapted to use PT4xx attachment, made in America.

MossRoad · Mar 23, 2010

BobRip said:
Dying and going to heaven.

DOH! Why didn't I see that! :laughing:

BobRip · Mar 25, 2010

Actually I kinda like the Tool cat. Attachments on the front (like God intended), short turning radius, diesel engine, dumpable bed in the back (oops, you will need a PT425 to load it), AC, quick connect, and they let you pay a whole lot more.

KentT · Mar 25, 2010

BobRip said:
Actually I kinda like the Tool cat. Attachments on the front (like God intended), short turning radius, diesel engine, dumpable bed in the back (oops, you will need a PT425 to load it), AC, quick connect, and they let you pay a whole lot more.

There were rumors a while back of a smaller version of the Toolcat coming out -- whatever happened with that?