dstig1
Super Member
- Joined
- Apr 7, 2010
- Messages
- 5,018
- Location
- W Wisc
- Tractor
- Kubota L5240 HSTC, JD X738 Mower, (Kubota L3130 HST - sold)
Chris,
Good job seeing my point rather than attacking me personally. I concur it has nothing to do with needing it. What my point was mainly to say that the other or 6th gear will rarely be seen by anyone except those stationed in the far north and even then, it's just a switch of gears. It doesn't become a 6 speed transmission below zero.
Let me tell you, the 6th gear will do more for the Ford trucks' performance than extra HP. I believe the 6th gear is what kept the 6,6L HD faster than the 6.4L SD.
There is a bit more behind the 1st gen Torqshift tranny. On the Ford Truck Enthusiast forum, there is a former tranny engineer from Ford who actually worked on it. He explained it pretty clearly. I'll paraphrase as I am not about to go searching for the post from a couple years back...
The 5 spd Torqshift is actually a 2x3 gear set. There is a 2 spd set that feeds a 3 spd (or maybe that is vice versa - you get the point) that feeds the output shaft. So technically it was capable of 6 gear ratios (2x3=6). When they chose the ratio set to fit the engines, two of them were within a gnat's behind of each other. As a result it sounds like they just decided to not use one of the possible ratios since it wouldn't help anything. During cold weather testing, they found that one of the shifts was hard to make reliably but that "extra" ratio combo was easier to do - and it was the ratio that was almost duplicating the other one noted above. So at low temps, the tranny defaults to making that "alternate" shift until it is warm. It was more of a driveability/reliability issue than anything else. In the second gen they made it into a full 6 spd, best I know. There were significant changes made to the whole system in that gen too, so it wasn't just a change in ratios.
Knowing the folks with panties in a bunch here, I will have to go find the citation directly, but I really don't want to waste an hour searching for it.
-Dave