Buying Advice Help me choose a tractor for mower / loader / driveway duties please!

   / Help me choose a tractor for mower / loader / driveway duties please! #1  

mstyer

New member
Joined
Aug 5, 2015
Messages
5
Location
Lambertville, NJ
Tractor
TBD
First time poster here, calling upon the collective wisdom of TBN. Please help me choose a tractor that will meet my needs!

My wife and I bought a house on 2.3 acres in central NJ at the beginning of the year. The house sits on top of a hill with about 1.5 acres mowable. The driveway is gravel and roughly 1000' long with about 200' of it at a 15% grade covered in patchy macadam. The seller left us a Husqvarna 23hp riding mower with a 48" deck and a Yamaha Big Bear ATV with a 48" plow operated by the winch. The ATV did well on the driveway, clearing everything in roughly an hour. I could run it in 3rd gear downhill as long as the snow wasn't too wet. Nuisances included manually changing the angle of the plow, shifting from 3rd gear to reverse and back again, only being able to lift the blade ~6", and lots of gravel pushed into my yard and the drainage ditch. The riding mower also does a decent job on the yard, although it takes over 2 hours to mow everything thanks to a dozen or so trees to work around and a fenced pool area. My biggest concern with the riding mower is how it handles side hills. There is one in particular, within the pool fence, that has me nervously sitting on the uphill side of the seat to keep that rear wheel on the ground. My coping strategy has been to drive up the hill at an angle, turn sharply, then come back down the hill in a series of overlapping /\ shapes.

Anyways, on to the fun stuff. I'm looking for a tractor that could potentially replace the riding mower, ATV with plow, and add some more capabilities. Things I plan on doing:

Mow 1.5 acres quickly and neatly
Clear snow from my gravel driveway with steep grades
Smooth driveway with a box blade
Move 30 cubic yards of fill dirt into a mini-BMX track
Rip up a garden plot
Remove several old peach trees (8-10" trunks)
...

Limitations:

Needs to fit through a 72" gate in the pool fence
I can store it inside, but the area is 14' deep and has a 7' high doorway.

I'm leaning towards a used tractor such as the 2520 with a loader and onramp mid-mount mower. There's a 2008 for sale locally with 145 hours and comes with a loader but no mower for a negotiable $12k. The mower would be $2-2.5k. A quick hitch hydraulic plow would be $750-1000. There's another 2520 nearby that has 148 hours but comes with a 200CX loader, 62D mower, and a bucket mount plow (manual angle?). That seller is asking for $16k.

Is it worth looking at an older tractor like a JD 855? Is the 2520 more tractor than I'll want for mowing around multiple trees? Is there a comparable Kubota model I should consider?

I have a JD dealer 18 miles away but a mild detour on the way home from work. I have a Kubota dealer 6.5 miles away.

Thank you!
 
   / Help me choose a tractor for mower / loader / driveway duties please!
  • Thread Starter
#2  
Anyone?
 
   / Help me choose a tractor for mower / loader / driveway duties please! #3  
Check Massey GC1705 or GC1715. They are priced close to what you have listed above for new and 5 year warranty.
 
   / Help me choose a tractor for mower / loader / driveway duties please! #4  
I don't know much about the JD brand. Mowing around trees and around a fenced in pool with a subcompact is possibe. You probably want to take the loader off when mowing. That's not a big task with modern tractors.

I'm not sure you're going to save any time mowing over the rider you have now.

With a gravel driveway, you don't want to clear down to bare gravel due to pushing gravel into the yard. I like to let the light snows go and just let it get packed down by my traffic. For medium snows a back blade will do fine even with the blade turned around to be less aggressive.

It's hard to get the picture of your challenges in the pool area. If it is small, you could use a regular walk behind mower
 
   / Help me choose a tractor for mower / loader / driveway duties please!
  • Thread Starter
#5  
I'll have to take a photo of the pool area this evening. Here's a pic of the steepest section of my driveway from this past winter. It makes a hard left where the tracks disappear. The VW didn't make it up that day.

2zh4m89.jpg
 
   / Help me choose a tractor for mower / loader / driveway duties please! #6  
It looks pretty clear in front of the VW. Surprised it didn't make it. Was it less clear up the hill or icy? I'm not sure a tractor will get it much cleaner. Maybe somewhat. Sometimes, you have to have a pile of sand that you can get some material to spread over icy spots, especially when it's steep.

My area is pretty flat, hence my suggestion to let the snow pack down. Probably won't work for you.
 
   / Help me choose a tractor for mower / loader / driveway duties please! #7  
Check Massey GC1705 or GC1715. They are priced close to what you have listed above for new and 5 year warranty.


I had an earlier model of this Massey as this member suggested (gc2310) these models would work fine. Also Kubota BX or small B series 26xx etc. several other manufacturers scut and cut would all be a consideration.

The 2520 w/o mower deck you mentioned would also work...take that $2500 for a MMM deck and put it towards a zero turn mower. That will mow the 1.5 acres you mentioned quickly and efficiently.
 
   / Help me choose a tractor for mower / loader / driveway duties please!
  • Thread Starter
#8  
I'm narrowing in my search on the Deere 8520, 855, and the Kubota B2630. I think those are the best compromise between small enough to mow around trees but big enough to pull a decent sized box blade.

Here's a pic of the slope in the pool area as promised. I measured it at 40%(!) and did the math as a sanity check. 6 ft of rise over a 15 ft distance. I'm wondering if I'd be better off with a rear finishing mower that I could back up this hill?

34q5xtk.jpg


PS. The driveway actually measured at 26% grade, not 15%.
 
   / Help me choose a tractor for mower / loader / driveway duties please! #9  
Skip getting a tractor mounted mower. Focus on a decent commercial grade ZTR (zero turn) instead. You'll have your entire property mowed in under an hour for sure. A good 48" ZTR will run you about $5k, but it'll last you forever, and will save so much time you'll wonder why they make "riding lawn mowers" anymore. Hustler, Gravely, Exmark, Scag, Ferris... To name a few.

That will free up your tractor requirements a bit also. A SCUT (sub compact utility tractor) from pretty much all the brands will be a good choice. Which dealers do you have around you? Buying new will get you a nice interest rate and a low payment. A used tractor (like the BX or a Massey) will be fine also.
 
   / Help me choose a tractor for mower / loader / driveway duties please! #10  
Chain a beater plow truck on all 4 corners and it will take care of that driveway. Won't get it any cleaner tho.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

Toro Z Master 2000 Zero Turn Mower (A50324)
Toro Z Master 2000...
2010 Ford Edge SE SUV (A51694)
2010 Ford Edge SE...
2016 Ford F-550 4x4 12FT Landscape Dump Truck (A51692)
2016 Ford F-550...
2017 Case CX130D Excavator (RIDE AND DRIVE) (A50774)
2017 Case CX130D...
2002 Ford F-150 4x4 Ext. Cab Pickup Truck (A50323)
2002 Ford F-150...
2010 Ford Edge SE SUV (A51694)
2010 Ford Edge SE...
 
Top