Lets say Im thankful for this thread!!!!!
I have a bunch of minimag leds, 2AA and 3AA, probably about 3 or 4 in various locations and toolpouches. Not a lot of lumens, but run a long time and make adequate light and are durable.
I also have a 3D MagLED, that has a very long run time and is built like a tank. Not a ton of lumen at 168 or so. I gave it a massive drop onto something hard and the actual LED chip fell off and made intermittent contact. A couple drops of CA glue later and it hasnet moved since. It usually lives in my truck door.
The reason I was thankful for this thread was that it made me go and check if mine was a 2 or 3D. In the process I discovered the one achilies heel of the Mags, Battery corrosion. These LEDs dont use much current at all, and as a result the batteries time expire before they are dead. THis particular MAGled was a free replacement from mag for my last one that died from battery corrosion. These particular older mags might not be the massive lumen throwers like some of the newer, smaller lights, but Mags warranty is second to none, even for battery corrosion issues. Problem for me is these heavy flashlights got to be sent back to mag for service and from here, last time, that was close to $40 IIRC. I caught this corrosion problem just in time, the last battery was starting to let go as seen in the pic.
https://goo.gl/photos/6Nixeer8QqENiYqa7
Side note, It appears that Mag is releasing some high lumen versions of the old flashlights (about time) For example a 625 lumen 3D
Maglite® ML300L? 3-Cell D LED Flashlight - Full Size - Flashlights Wonder if they improved the focus on these new LEDs too???
I also have a couple Pelican Stealthlights in 4AA Xenon. They reside at work. They really throw a beam and are nice and light, but Im glad work buys the batteries! Id strongly consider one of the Stealthlights in LED. The specs say both pelicans should have less output than my big mag led, but in practice, it seems to me like the Stealthlite has just as much light as the Mag, it must come down to lens design being better on the Pelicans???