atsah
Elite Member
Years ago if someone knocked on my door it was probably some kind of emergency, times have changed, most everyone has a cell phone and there are a lot more people on drugs and or up to no good..
Thanks for the update.Op here
Re dog - we have one. She is an awful watch dog. We love her anyway.
Re wife actively carrying - she will not. So need best 2nd choice.
As for those who say I over reacted.... wrong. Dude comes up to my BACK DOOR. Only way to do that and not see the no trespass sign and not set off the drive way alarm is to not enter the property from the driveway.
Out come is the police did not come back to the house. They found him and he was wanted on warrants. That does not matter to my resolution of the matter in the moment because of course I did not know that. I had to call dispatch to find that out.
I cannot imagine opening the door in that situation. That is just crazy talk.
Indiana law is if the person is in the house I am justified in shooting. Outside the house it becomes much more complicated.
From a personal standpoint I would not want to have to live with having killed someone. However had things gone the other way and had he tried to break in there is no doubt in my mind I would have shot.
Thanks for the update.
He had warrants? I am shocked, SHOCKED I tell you! He seemed like such a nice guy. He was probably just about getting his life on track, and you wouldn't even let him use your phone. :laughing:
Op here
Re dog - we have one. She is an awful watch dog. We love her anyway.
Well, we have two - at least they bark like crazy.
But, they only bark because they are happy to see every human; I mean after all, every human exists just to give them treats and rub their bellies.
Bonehead post of the century...Devil's advocate here:
Real crime of the century: A guy walks up to your house and asking to use the phone....and.......??? :confused3:
Your wife screams bloody murder, yells "Get the gun!" and calls the cops. Why?
Do you have "No Trespassing" signs?
You ask him to leave and he does (while you're making (very thinly veiled) threats about shooting him). OK. Done. What's the crime?
So, what was her complaint to the police? What was HER suspicion based on?
What did the police do? Arrest him for existing? Excessive tattoos? Failure to drive a car? Pedestrian-ing without a cell phone?
Sounds like there was only one party (not counting the cops you brought) bringing gun play and threats of violence to the scene and creating a disturbance.
Bonehead post of the century...
Bonehead post of the century...
Not so, considering the information available when he posted.Yup...