Pretty frustrated. Put in the shaft and have a leak on one side. Its the side that received the shaft from the inside vs the outside. Something I noticed was that the shaft was angled a bit low when it came up to the bushing. I used a punch and a jack stand as a fulcrum to (as best as I could) center the shaft before pushing it the rest of the way through. Obviously something went wrong because when I pulled the shaft back out there was a nice chunk missing from the teflon ring.
Now...I had the foresight to purchase an extra ring. However, I did not buy an extra o-ring. First question is, how likely is it that I damaged the o-ring as well? My thought is likely enough that I should just bite the bullet and take the hour to go buy another one at the dealer. I guess I could try to pull the o-ring to inspect for damage, if I damage it I was going to replace it anyway...if its good then I save myself some time.
What can I do to prevent this happening again?
Is there something I need to do in order to center the shaft better?
The shaft is beveled and I made sure there weren't any burrs. I also took the extra step to smooth the bevel out a little with a file and sandpaper. Should I smooth it out more? Did I install backwards? I didn't see any difference in the ends, so I don't think that's it.
Should I use the old shaft from the outside to seat the teflon ring better before trying to push the new one in again from the inside?
I'm out of ideas beyond the above, so I'll pass this one to you all now. Thanks again for the help!

