Take it from a farmer- you are always better off buying a vehicle (or piece of equipment) that is made to handle a load in its base form than a lighter duty vehicle beefed up to handle the same load.
The 150 may have overload springs, but the 3/4 ton usually has bigger brakes, bigger rims & higher weight rating tires, heavier frame, larger axles, bigger torque converter, bigger steering box and front end components and probably a heavier duty engine.
I constantly hear guys bragging up these small displacement engines as having the same HP as a bigger 5.3L or 6L GM gas engine. The smaller Ford eco boost engines are nice and economical, but they don稚 have the rotating mass of the bigger, heavier engines. Theyæ±*e not built to take the rigors of hauling heavy loads. Then thereç—´ the stopping power aspect. A 5,000lb 1/2 ton truck will not stop a load as well as a 3/4 ton 6,500lb truck.
Compromise elsewhere
I'm no economist but I think the new vehicle prices are overdue for a market correction. I know I can't afford one. 60 grand for an F150? Gimme a break! I can buy a lot of repairs on my old truck for that kind of money and I still love driving it.
On the tractor front I have started seeing a few good deals on used equipment even at the dealerships. THAT doesn't make sense to me while some buyers are running scared of the emission tractors.
With bigger trucks you are spot on with bigger brakes, bigger suspension, heavier diff etc that stuff is what really matters when hauling weight around. To be fair when comparing some of these 1/2 tons to 3/4 tons today not counting engines just the truck the 1/2 tons are much closer then they used to be.
Now where I will differ is in motor. I have owened the 3.5 ecoboost, chevy 5.3, ford 5.0 and the ram 5.7. From my experience numbers wise not only does the ecoboost out perform but it did in real life as well. I would disagree that they arent built to handle load. For starters the 3.5 weighs 449lbs, Ford 5.o weighs 430 and chevy 5.3 weighs 476lbs. Your really not talking about engines that are that different in size. But yes size of heads matter, amount of pistons, etc. You also could have a point where forced induction will prematurely kill the engine compared to an NA engine, and yeah thats possible. But with that said these ecoboost engines have been on the market now for a decade and have been relatively issue free and have been proven if you go out and look at some of the date. Now if your talking about buying a truck thats a 3/4 ton with a diesel and plan on beating it for 200-300k miles you may have a point. But if you are talking about the average driver doing 12-15k a year keeping a vehicle for 5-6 years the ecoboost will do just fine.
I don’t want a small displacement forced induction engine for anything other than minimal frequency heavy towing or frequent lower weight towing. And that might be your sweet spot.
The GM 6L is a heavy duty light truck gas engine and it will do better than a 3.5L eco boost for true truck useage. For driving around mostly unloaded, ecoboost
Nahhhh, the F150 is the weekend warrior truck. :laughing:
That makes sense for a farmer or for anyone else that uses their truck daily at full capacity. For someone like myself that might hook up a travel trailer four times a year, the extra payload capacity of the heavy F150 might have made sense, because you're talking 20-30% better fuel economy and still getting a truck that can handle the load you are putting on it.
Doesn't matter to me either way, i wound up with a 2500HD, it's a great truck and I'll probably pick up a little Jeep to use as a daily here soon. But if I were someone looking to tow a travel trailer with a family of four and a couple of dogs, a heavy F150 would be on my list - assuming you can find one.
I'm no economist but I think the new vehicle prices are overdue for a market correction. I know I can't afford one. 60 grand for an F150? Gimme a break! I can buy a lot of repairs on my old truck for that kind of money and I still love driving it.
On the tractor front I have started seeing a few good deals on used equipment even at the dealerships. THAT doesn't make sense to me while some buyers are running scared of the emission tractors.
Id agree if you are looking at industrial operations certain set ups are definitely require. I will say this though the Chevy 6.0 is due to be brought out back and shot much better NA engines out there. With that said if I was buying a heavy duty truck for daily heavy duty operations a gasser has no business in that truck and should get a diesel. Furthermore if you are doing high frequency towing a diesel is much better all around and might save you money eventually. I had a Diesel 2012 F250 getting 17mpg and 13-14 while towing and could tow a house where as my buddies 6.o chevy got 12mpg and less with towing and couldnt get out of its own way