89,000lb wheel loader or 18,000lb backhoe???

   / 89,000lb wheel loader or 18,000lb backhoe??? #1  

1990BB

New member
Joined
Jul 27, 2020
Messages
11
Tractor
ford 750
*sorry for the long winded post*

My family and I just purchased 80 acres here in central FL, the plans are to eventually build 3 homes and maybe a granny-flat. It is a wooded lot with sand pine, long leaf pine, water oak, live oak, blackjack oat, the occasional palmettos and even some cypress by the lake. There is only one cleared spot that is nearly 3 acres and that is being fenced for my mothers nags. The rest we are only wanting to clear enough for the home sites and then another 3 acres for my lady's mini animals (goats, cow and donkey). So that means 3 drievways, 3 home sites, and an additional 3 acres are going to need to be cleared.

Now im "do it yourself" kinda guy, always do our own work with pretty much everything. Unfortunately I dont have the equipment or rather the experience on what im going to be up against with this much land clearing. I have ran tractors and backhoes for relatively short periods of time, and used them to clear various trees and stumps, but nothing involving full acres of land.

The good thing is, the homes arnt going to be built for another 1-2 years, so i am weighing the options as to weather i should get the equipment and chip away at it slowly (which is what i would like to do) or to rent and not worry about the wear and tear on a machine of my own, or the just hire it out.

Talking to a few people and reading the forums i have been trying to figure out the best route on which piece of machinery i sould get. And judging by what i could find, a decent size excavator with a thumb is the best stratagy. Unfortunately in my price range $15-18K, im mostly finding older backhoes, dozers and wheel loaders. I have found the occasional mid to large excavator but they havent been in any kind of condition I would be willing to spend my money on.

I understand the older backhoes and dozers are a risky idea, especially given the amount of abuse they have put through and the work ill be adding to get the job done. I know a good size dozer with a tree spear will push them out with the root balls, but im not the knowledgeable in the undercarriage on tracked machines and the dozers are limited to just kinda pushing the stuff around. The backhoes are on the lighter side being 14-18k lbs, and im not that keen on digging out the roots and trying to shove them over. slight breeze or wrong call on which way it wants to go and im in some quick trouble. Cutting the trees and digging the roots is what ive normally done, but that takes a bit of time and once the weight of the tree i gone, pulling that stump is hard work sometimes on the machine, especially with the bigger pines having a 10ft deep root ball.

This is what brings me to favoring the larger wheel loaders 50,000lb or more,,, they are built pretty tough, higher hp, alot of weight and much higher lifting capacity which seams to be the ticket when clearing tree's. Also have to ability to scoop them up and dump them in a pile unlike the dozer.

I would consider renting, but i work a fair amount of hours as is and being that im not a "skilled" operator of either machine, i dont think ill get my moneys worth out of it or have a clue how long it will take. The larger excavators are like $3500 a week and i would only be able to get a few full days on it at max even on the weekend...

Now i understand hiring out would be much faster and easier, but down here its a bit more expensive then i was originally expecting.. I have gotten 5 estimates so far for a driveway, the first thing i need in order to get started on my section of the land. My spot is roughly 1100ft to the back and per county code i have to have a 40ft easement. So roughly 1 acre of land. Out of the 5 estimates i have been quoted between $7-12k:shocked::shocked:... for 1 acre! and that was only clearing out the root balls of 20ft in width so my driveway doesnt form craters later on... to think of what i would cost for the home sites and acreage i will defiantly be buying or renting..

so far i have found a ford 655a, 755b international 3600, a cat 980b, a kumatsu im waiting on some info on and a clark 275c. All of which fit the price, distance and acceptable condition. Personally i think i would be pretty fun to run the 275c around ;):laughing:

I appreciate the group and hope to hear some thoughts on this.

Thanks,
Jon
 
   / 89,000lb wheel loader or 18,000lb backhoe??? #2  
they are called "loader" and not "digger" for a reason.

sounds like you need an excavator, or the biggest construction backhoe you can get for your budget. It seems like you will be doing more digging than moving piles.

that clark does sound fun though.
 
   / 89,000lb wheel loader or 18,000lb backhoe??? #3  
The Clark and 980 are pit loaders. Great for loading trucks and mining, probably not so great on a house lot. They will be very big, awkward and clumsy. And may get stuck. What happens when you get a 980 stuck and can't push your way out? And they are old. Price out a replacement tires for them too. ;)

If I were you, I'd look at two options. 1) A package deal for all of the site work (clearing, driveways, utilities, etc) and 2) A newish mid size excavator (10-15 ton) to do it myself and either sell after or keep for farm chores.

Either way, you are probably investing much more than your budget.
 
   / 89,000lb wheel loader or 18,000lb backhoe??? #4  
More and more, no such thing as buying used equipment and saving money. It used to be that old equipment was simple and could be maintained/repaired at moderate cost. Now 20 year old equipment is full of computers too. And older stuff is usually just too worn out.

Really, the only way I see a way, is to buy good equipment that is a few years old, use it, TAKE CARE OF IT, and sell it for probably close to what you paid for it. If the dollar continues to go for a crap, the dollar amount might actually be higher.
 
   / 89,000lb wheel loader or 18,000lb backhoe???
  • Thread Starter
#5  
they are called "loader" and not "digger" for a reason.

sounds like you need an excavator, or the biggest construction backhoe you can get for your budget. It seems like you will be doing more digging than moving piles.

that clark does sound fun though.

I forgot to mention that all i had listed above had a root rake either on it or came with it. I wont need it to dig if i can get push it over, hence going with a much heavier machine VS a smaller one with digging ability.
 
   / 89,000lb wheel loader or 18,000lb backhoe???
  • Thread Starter
#6  
The Clark and 980 are pit loaders. Great for loading trucks and mining, probably not so great on a house lot. They will be very big, awkward and clumsy. And may get stuck. What happens when you get a 980 stuck and can't push your way out? And they are old. Price out a replacement tires for them too. ;)

If I were you, I'd look at two options. 1) A package deal for all of the site work (clearing, driveways, utilities, etc) and 2) A newish mid size excavator (10-15 ton) to do it myself and either sell after or keep for farm chores.

Either way, you are probably investing much more than your budget.

I was actually a little concerned with the getting stuck as well, thats a massive machine to try and dig out :laughing: I definitely see that as sound advice, but a package deal just isnt attainable at this time. i have a little while to save up but im anxious to get started! :D
 
   / 89,000lb wheel loader or 18,000lb backhoe??? #7  
Big heavy machinery gets stuck waaaaay easier than you think and if it's very stuck, it's very costly to get back out!

My friend has a bigger loader, he's had it stuck 2 or 3 times in places that you would never believe it would get stuck.

SR
 
   / 89,000lb wheel loader or 18,000lb backhoe??? #8  
People who are ignorant to such matters shouldn't try and re-invent the wheel.

I thought I would use a 12 ton zoom boom for snow removal. Had quarry type tires. Took it out first time in winter and it slid out of control sideways for a good distance, fortunately not hitting anything. That was the last time it came out in the winter. Easy to dream up all kinds of stuff in ones head! lol

Oh yeah, got it stuck in soft ground too, but again (fortunately) it managed to eventually push itself out, because I had nothing to pull it out.
 
   / 89,000lb wheel loader or 18,000lb backhoe??? #9  
More and more, no such thing as buying used equipment and saving money. It used to be that old equipment was simple and could be maintained/repaired at moderate cost. Now 20 year old equipment is full of computers too. And older stuff is usually just too worn out.

Really, the only way I see a way, is to buy good equipment that is a few years old, use it, TAKE CARE OF IT, and sell it for probably close to what you paid for it. If the dollar continues to go for a crap, the dollar amount might actually be higher.

EXCELLENT advice !!!!!
 
   / 89,000lb wheel loader or 18,000lb backhoe??? #10  
I’m not sure what you’re going to do with a 45 ton loader. It might have the brute force to clear trees but it’s too big to do anything with. It’s too big to work with, it’s too big to work on ( which you’ll be doing plenty of ) it’s too big to move, too big to get unstuck. A homeowner buying a loader that big for property management is a terrible idea.
 
   / 89,000lb wheel loader or 18,000lb backhoe??? #11  
If you think $15-18K is expensive then you definitely wont be able to afford to fill the fuel tank...expect to burn through 100+gal of fuel every day on the older big pay loaders. Get an account set up with bulk fuel delivery, you will empty a 500gal fuel tank every week.
 
   / 89,000lb wheel loader or 18,000lb backhoe??? #12  
Get the backhoe and hire out the big stuff. There will be plenty of tractor work to be done after the big stuff is gone. The backhoe will be more versatile for the other stuff you will want to do.
 
   / 89,000lb wheel loader or 18,000lb backhoe??? #13  
In the budget range of $15-18K I wouldn't look past a tracked skidloader. You would be rather amazed what you can do with a 8-9000 lbs tracked skidsteer, I'm thinking like a Bobcat T250 or T300. It may not handle popping your largest rootwads out of the dirt but it will likely push a few around and will definitely be handy to have around for construction.
 
   / 89,000lb wheel loader or 18,000lb backhoe??? #14  
I bought a New Holland 555E that is 2 wheel drive and open station. It has proven to be the Swiss Army Knife of equipment. It will do pretty much everything. At 80 hp, it has enough hydraulic power to dig out the biggest pine tree, and I've taken them out with 3 foot thick trunks!! For years, I dragged the trees to the burn pile, then pushed them up with the loader bucket. Eventually, I converted it to a Quick Attach System that I can use a grapple, pallet forks, and hay forks on it too. This was a huge game changer. I'm able to clear and clean up my place a lot faster and easier!!!

Excavator is the best at clearing trees, but it's horrible at moving them any distance. Backhoe does both.

Wheel Loader is great at loading material, and carrying it over a distance, but horrible at taking out trees. Backhoe does both.

Dozer is great at grading land, but horrible at taking out trees and moving them to the burn pile. Backhoe does both.

Find a backhoe with a quick change front bucket and it will be the one machine that does it all.
 
   / 89,000lb wheel loader or 18,000lb backhoe??? #15  
What you're doing is called site preparation. Hire that type of work done by professionals who have the proper equipment and know what they're doing. You're asking for trouble trying to do it yourself.

Good luck and stay safe.
 
   / 89,000lb wheel loader or 18,000lb backhoe??? #16  
I always wanted construction equipment. One day back in the late 80s or 90s I was doing some phone work at a DEERE construction equipment dealer. Got talking to the service manager about a 644 loader or similar and he showed me the invoice for a torque converter repair. I think my construction equipment fantasies ended that day.
 
   / 89,000lb wheel loader or 18,000lb backhoe??? #17  
I bought a New Holland 555E that is 2 wheel drive and open station. It has proven to be the Swiss Army Knife of equipment. It will do pretty much everything. At 80 hp, it has enough hydraulic power to dig out the biggest pine tree, and I've taken them out with 3 foot thick trunks!! For years, I dragged the trees to the burn pile, then pushed them up with the loader bucket. Eventually, I converted it to a Quick Attach System that I can use a grapple, pallet forks, and hay forks on it too. This was a huge game changer. I'm able to clear and clean up my place a lot faster and easier!!!

Excavator is the best at clearing trees, but it's horrible at moving them any distance. Backhoe does both.

Wheel Loader is great at loading material, and carrying it over a distance, but horrible at taking out trees. Backhoe does both.

Dozer is great at grading land, but horrible at taking out trees and moving them to the burn pile. Backhoe does both.

Find a backhoe with a quick change front bucket and it will be the one machine that does it all.


Eddie is giving you some very good advice here in my opinion. I have a Ford 555A which has very useful and versatile over the years.
 
   / 89,000lb wheel loader or 18,000lb backhoe???
  • Thread Starter
#19  
no I don't believe my budget is an expensive one for a piece of equipment,, not by a long shot. its just what I have to work with at the moment. And running the e275c wasn't realistic, just more of a cool factor being able to play with that big of a toy lol
you are certainly right, I definitely wouldn't want to have to fuel that beast all the time!!
 
   / 89,000lb wheel loader or 18,000lb backhoe???
  • Thread Starter
#20  
In the budget range of $15-18K I wouldn't look past a tracked skidloader. You would be rather amazed what you can do with a 8-9000 lbs tracked skidsteer, I'm thinking like a Bobcat T250 or T300. It may not handle popping your largest rootwads out of the dirt but it will likely push a few around and will definitely be handy to have around for construction.

I have looked into it, between there versatility and the attachments you can get for them I would consider it. just haven't really found any in my area in my price range and shape I would be willing to buy.
 

Marketplace Items

Commercial Lawn Mower 652R (A56859)
Commercial Lawn...
Redirective Crash Cushion Guardrail (A59230)
Redirective Crash...
Land Pride FDR1660 (A53317)
Land Pride FDR1660...
(2) BKT TR-387 TIRES (A60432)
(2) BKT TR-387...
HYDRAULIC THUMB FOR MINI EXCAVATOR (A58214)
HYDRAULIC THUMB...
1996 International Water Truck with a Caterpillar Engine (A61306)
1996 International...
 
Top