Absolutely.
Most flooded cell (and AGM batteries useful life (maximum rated CCA) decreases substantially after 4 years. The issue is always plate sulfatiion and contrary to polular belief, batteries dont fail because of the cold, they fail because of the heat in the summer months. They get week during hot weather and then when it gets cold out and you require more CCA to get a motor started, they cannot deliver it so they poop out.
My only prerequisite for buying ANY flooded cell battery is I always buy them from a volume dealer, in my case my local Freightliner dealer, because the turnover is large so the batteries are very new. Once any flooded cell battery has the electrolyte installed, it's getting old so a battery sitting on a shelf somewhere waiting for you to buy it, is loosing it's useful life. Any battery with a dusty top is a no buy. it's old and getting feeble. Don't matter squat what the date code says when you buy it, the real date of manufacture isn't listed, just the by date and that is meaningless. I get my car / truck batteries at a big box store or Wal Mart because the turnover is always great. the faster the turn over the better the battery is. Or... Buy a dry charged battery and add the electrolyte yourself. That will be the freshest you can get. Finally, always trickle charge a battery before installing it. Bring it up to full charge and then install it for use.